trustmebro.reviews

Weber Smokey Mountain

Physical Product · Pots, pans & cast iron · 76 mentions · 2 subreddits · discussed in r/smoking, r/BBQ

Reddit take

Not enough linked mention summaries yet; the source excerpts below are the evidence.

Pros

  • Once I replaced the door with stainless and bought a new fire basket from Arbor Fabricating with the minion starter, I can run my WSM without touching it at least eight hours without touching it after it's set and steady.
  • Coming from a pellet smoker but wanting real wood only two options I see are Weber smokey mountain (as mentioned) or the Masterbuilt gravity smokers.
  • WSM is a great option because it lets you do two big pulled pork or several racks of ribs or a very large brisket low and slow without much fuss, using charcoal briquettes, or lump charcoal, along with adding a few wood chunks for the ac...
  • Probably get a WSM
  • One load of charcoal is enough for 8 hours or so in my wsm.

Cons

  • been smoking on my WSM for ages so I'm excited to finally try my hand at an offset.
  • On a WSM, which I was using at the time, it comes from the bottom.
  • I’ve had some challenges on my previous 3 attempts at ribs on my WSM but think I’ve finally nailed it.
  • I have a wsm. It’s too small for the amount I cook.
  • I’ve done brisket three or four times on my WSM and I just can’t get it right. Always comes off looking promising, but then very quickly dries out.

Sentiment

63 positive (83%) · 7 mixed (9%) · 6 negative (8%)

Trust + time weighted score: +77% · raw score 75%

What redditors said (10 of 76)

Once I replaced the door with stainless and bought a new fire basket from Arbor Fabricating with the minion starter, I can run my WSM without touching it at least eight hours without touching it after it's set and steady.
positive · u/C****s · r/smoking · comment · Jan 9, 2025 · open on Reddit ↗
been smoking on my WSM for ages so I'm excited to finally try my hand at an offset.
mixed · u/S****6 · r/smoking · Nov 8, 2025 · open on Reddit ↗
Coming from a pellet smoker but wanting real wood only two options I see are Weber smokey mountain (as mentioned) or the Masterbuilt gravity smokers.
positive · u/d****t · r/BBQ · comment · Dec 30, 2025 · open on Reddit ↗
WSM is a great option because it lets you do two big pulled pork or several racks of ribs or a very large brisket low and slow without much fuss, using charcoal briquettes, or lump charcoal, along with adding a few wood chunks for the actual smoke flavor.
positive · u/p****y · r/BBQ · comment · Dec 30, 2025 · open on Reddit ↗
Probably get a WSM
positive · u/K****0 · r/BBQ · comment · Dec 29, 2025 · open on Reddit ↗
One load of charcoal is enough for 8 hours or so in my wsm.
positive · u/H****x · r/BBQ · comment · Dec 28, 2025 · open on Reddit ↗
I too recently made bacon using a similar brine and smoke process. I too have a WSM. My WSM is the 18” version.
positive · u/O****6 · r/smoking · comment · Dec 22, 2025 · open on Reddit ↗
I’ve got a WSM that cooks great, but I’m thinking of upgrading soon.
positive · u/_****s · r/smoking · comment · Dec 22, 2025 · open on Reddit ↗
Pit barrel cooker or a Weber Smokey mountain all good to begin on and last you for sometime.
positive · u/L****p · r/smoking · comment · Dec 19, 2025 · open on Reddit ↗
Very versatile. I use my WSM like a drum quite a bit.
positive · u/L****p · r/smoking · comment · Dec 19, 2025 · open on Reddit ↗

Compare

Related