trustmebro.reviews

Tudor Black Bay 58

Physical Product · Watches · 10 mentions · 1 subreddit · discussed in r/Watches

Reddit take

Not enough linked mention summaries yet; the source excerpts below are the evidence.

Pros

  • I sold almost all of it and got myself a bb58 that I wear daily. Turns out I mostly wore my latest watch all the time until I got a new one and the older ones was just collecting dust.
  • BB58 - my first watch and could potentially be my last with how well this thing wears with nearly anything!
  • I have a seamaster, bb58, and sbga375. I bought all of them grey market brand new for under $4000 USD.
  • Meanwhile the Tudor was more of a slow burn. More subtle and won't knock your socks off. But the more you wear it, the more I find to appreciate. ... And I find that mine looks better and better with each little scratch. It looks worn-in...
  • i say this as someone who has owned a SMP for 10+ years and have worn a bb58 almost daily for the last year

Cons

  • For years I wanted a BB58. I finally got one. I had it for a year and sold it.
  • They all get BB58s, Seamaster 300, AT, etc when getting the internship to fit in but then have that "oh shit I don't have the money to pay off the credit card now" moment upon rejection.
  • Both watches wear beautifully on my 7' wrist. I put the BB58 on a strap because I didn't enjoy the Oyster bracelet that much, and the brown leather emphasizes the vintage feel of the watch.
  • The 149 and BB58 have been diving, maybe 8 others have made it into a pool or the ocean

Sentiment

6 positive (60%) · 4 mixed (40%) · 0 negative (0%)

Trust + time weighted score: +61% · raw score 60%

What redditors said (10 of 10)

I sold almost all of it and got myself a bb58 that I wear daily. Turns out I mostly wore my latest watch all the time until I got a new one and the older ones was just collecting dust.
positive · u/m****u · r/Watches · comment · Aug 24, 2025 · open on Reddit ↗
BB58 - my first watch and could potentially be my last with how well this thing wears with nearly anything!
positive · u/t***r · r/Watches · comment · Aug 23, 2025 · open on Reddit ↗
I have a seamaster, bb58, and sbga375. I bought all of them grey market brand new for under $4000 USD.
positive · u/D****r · r/Watches · comment · Aug 13, 2025 · open on Reddit ↗
For years I wanted a BB58. I finally got one. I had it for a year and sold it.
mixed · u/E****o · r/Watches · comment · Aug 12, 2025 · open on Reddit ↗
They all get BB58s, Seamaster 300, AT, etc when getting the internship to fit in but then have that "oh shit I don't have the money to pay off the credit card now" moment upon rejection.
mixed · u/y****n · r/Watches · comment · Jul 10, 2025 · open on Reddit ↗
Meanwhile the Tudor was more of a slow burn. More subtle and won't knock your socks off. But the more you wear it, the more I find to appreciate. ... And I find that mine looks better and better with each little scratch. It looks worn-in like good leather shoes, not worn out like a sweater covered in pills. Which means I never really take it off.
positive · u/B****0 · r/Watches · comment · Jan 15, 2025 · open on Reddit ↗
i say this as someone who has owned a SMP for 10+ years and have worn a bb58 almost daily for the last year
positive · u/S****t · r/Watches · comment · Jan 15, 2025 · open on Reddit ↗
I bought the BB58 this past November. I am absolutely in love with it. I originally wanted the Pelagos but it was just a bit too pricey at the time. Zero regrets with BB58 highly recommend it will definitely be my most worn this year
positive · u/m****s · r/Watches · comment · Jan 10, 2025 · open on Reddit ↗
Both watches wear beautifully on my 7' wrist. I put the BB58 on a strap because I didn't enjoy the Oyster bracelet that much, and the brown leather emphasizes the vintage feel of the watch.
mixed · u/C****1 · r/Watches · comment · Jan 10, 2025 · open on Reddit ↗
The 149 and BB58 have been diving, maybe 8 others have made it into a pool or the ocean
mixed · u/B****s · r/Watches · comment · Jan 1, 2025 · open on Reddit ↗

Compare

Related