Proper Cloth
Reddit take
AI summary of the Reddit excerpts below — not a quote
Proper Cloth is a highly regarded made-to-measure (MTM) brand, particularly praised for its extensive fabric selection and high-quality collar designs. While it sits at a higher price point than entry-level retailers, users generally find the premium justified by the level of fit customization and material quality, provided the initial measurements are accurately established.
Pros
- Wide variety of high-quality fabrics and patterns
- Excellent collar designs and specific customization options
- Professional in-person measurement services available at NYC showrooms
- Free remakes offered to help first-time customers dial in their fit
- Detailed measurement system allows for a very precise fit once calibrated
Cons
- Higher price point compared to competitors like SuitSupply or mass-market brands
- Occasional fit inconsistency even when using the same measurement profile
- Customization is restricted to what is available in the online configurator
- Some users find the standard collar scales to be too small
Caveats
- Users strongly advise getting measured in person at a showroom if possible to avoid DIY measurement errors
- Manufacturing is located in Vietnam, which some users noted as a consideration regarding price-to-origin ratio
- The 'free remake' policy may not always be sufficient to fix significant measurement errors on the first try
Best for
- Individuals seeking high-quality made-to-measure dress shirts and chinos
- People who can visit a physical showroom in Manhattan for professional fitting
- Those who have a specific shirt they love and want to replicate its measurements
Avoid if
- You are looking for budget-friendly pricing similar to Banana Republic or Uniqlo
- You require deep customization beyond the standard options provided in an online configurator
- You are uncomfortable with the trial-and-error process often associated with MTM clothing
This summary uses balanced time weighting with about a 18-month half-life. The evidence comes from 30 selected mentions with a median age of 436 days, primarily sourced from r/malefashionadvice.
Sentiment
27 positive (77%) · 5 mixed (14%) · 3 negative (9%)
Trust + time weighted score: +68% · raw score 69%
What redditors said (10 of 35)
Proper cloth has some really nice fabrics if you get your measurements dialed in.
or I think Proper Cloth MTM plays
If you're looking for more formal clothing, you can try Proper Cloth made to measure, they have physical locations in Manhattan and will measure you in-store for your first garment and for remakes.
If you do proper cloth go in person and get measured by them. Even with measurements you know work for you they tend to fuck garmets up and the free remake isn’t enough
Proper Cloth.
Proper cloth is decent value but they don't allow for any customization beyond what their configurator allows, and I find all of their collars to be too small for my taste.
My go to currently is Proper Cloth. They are literally 5-10 mins walk from my office in NYC.
I also have liked some of proper cloth’s items, but they seem to be slightly more expensive than suitsupply.
Proper Cloth would be a start if you have all the measurements already.
While I like them, I don’t love them. I feel there is variation in fitting even when they stitch to the same size. Finishing feels ok.
Compare
Proper Cloth vs Spier & MackayProper Cloth vs SunspelProper Cloth vs Charles Tyrwhitt