Poshmark
Reddit take
AI summary of the Reddit excerpts below — not a quote
Poshmark is a widely used secondhand marketplace particularly favored for finding established "mall brands" and high-quality staples like wool and merino at significant discounts. It is frequently cited as a go-to platform for Millennials and Gen X shoppers looking for specific items from brands like Lululemon, Anthropologie, and J. Crew. While the platform's offer system makes negotiation easy, some users report frustrations with inactive sellers and an influx of "professional" resellers whose communication can be intrusive.
Pros
- Excellent for sourcing established brands like Lululemon, Madewell, and Anthropologie
- Strong presence and active user base in Canada
- Easy-to-use offer system that facilitates frequent price negotiations
- Great for finding high-quality materials (wool, merino, silk) at low price points
- Effective for finding exact replacements or different sizes of discontinued clothing items
Cons
- Presence of inactive sellers who leave listings up but do not respond to offers
- Cluttered experience due to 'professional' sellers and high volumes of social notifications
- Common for items to receive many 'likes' without any serious offers or sales
Caveats
- The platform's demographic leans older (Millennials/Gen X) compared to trend-focused competitors like Depop
- Buying success often depends on knowing your specific brand measurements beforehand
- Users frequently recommend cross-checking listings on eBay and Mercari for the best pricing
Best for
- Shoppers looking for contemporary mall brands and mid-tier luxury
- Canadian residents seeking a robust secondhand fashion marketplace
- Bargain hunters looking for high-quality vintage wool and outerwear
Avoid if
- You are primarily looking for the latest Gen Z-focused streetwear or micro-trends
- You prefer a purely transactional experience without social features or negotiation
This summary uses balanced time weighting with about a 6-month half-life. The evidence is older (median age of approximately 380 days), which may mean some observations regarding seller activity or app features have changed.
Sentiment
45 positive (76%) · 8 mixed (14%) · 6 negative (10%)
Trust + time weighted score: +64% · raw score 66%
What redditors said (10 of 59)
And at least half my wardrobe now is 2nd hand from Mercari/Depop/Poshmark.
Poshmark: older audience (millennials, Gen X), name brand is more important (think big, well-established brands like Lululemon, Anthropologie). ... Offering is much easier and is used more often.
I recently bought a bright purple wool blend pea coat one on Poshmark for less than $70.
Depop has very little and like you, Poshmark has been a joke.
eBay, Poshmark, etc. are all solid options for less expensive suits and will be your friend.
And Poshmark. Canada has a pretty decent Poshmark site!
Poshmark is now also going the same way. [referring to Pinterest being half ads and AI]
the secondhand stores in my area are terrible, Poshmark is unusable these days, I have no idea what brands to look for
Poshmark has been my main guilty pleasure lately, because of the colors and because I’m sick of plasticky sweaters
I look for them specifically on Poshmark and I’ve had success with that!