Nutricost
Reddit take
AI summary of the Reddit excerpts below — not a quote
Nutricost is primarily recognized as a budget-friendly supplement brand that offers high value for the price, though user sentiment is polarized regarding its quality and transparency. While many customers appreciate the brand for affordable staples like creatine, others describe the products as "hit or miss" and express skepticism about the brand's third-party testing claims compared to more established competitors.
Pros
- Highly budget-friendly and cost-effective for daily use
- Wide variety of products available through major retailers like Amazon
- Well-regarded for specific items like Creapure creatine monohydrate
- Generally considered a solid option for those on a strict budget
Cons
- Inconsistent effectiveness reported across different types of supplements
- Poor flavor profiles, specifically noted in their protein powder offerings
- Lack of transparency regarding third-party testing and difficulty obtaining COAs (Certificates of Analysis)
- Perceived lower potency and quality compared to brands like NOW or Thorne
Caveats
- Some users describe purchasing from the brand as a 'dice roll' regarding whether a specific supplement will work as expected
- There are conflicting reports on whether the brand's raw ingredients are high quality or sourced from the cheapest available manufacturers
- A ConsumerLab test reportedly showed their nattokinase was among several brands that did not meet label claims
Best for
- Budget-conscious consumers looking for basic supplements
- Purchasing high-volume staples like creatine monohydrate
- Users who prioritize price over premium brand reputation
Avoid if
- You require verified third-party testing documentation for every purchase
- You are sensitive to the taste and texture of protein powders
- You prefer brands with a more consistent track record for potency and purity
This summary uses balanced time weighting with about a 18-month half-life. The evidence is based on 21 mentions with a median age of approximately 13 months, reflecting a mix of older and more recent perspectives.
Sentiment
11 positive (52%) · 5 mixed (24%) · 5 negative (24%)
Trust + time weighted score: +30% · raw score 29%
What redditors said (10 of 21)
Hate to break it to you but those are the two worst brands on the planet and have less than 20% potency. Their raw ingredients come from the cheapest oversees manufactures. I know the founder of Nutricost Mr. Min. Cheap and pump volume
That consumerLab test showing only 5 out of 8 nattokinase supplements hitting their label claims really highlights why it's so hard to trust what's on the bottle. The list includes brands like Doctor's Best, NOW, Nutricost and more.
Nutricost
Most people in Canada stick with Creatine Monohydrate – Optimum Nutrition, Thorne, AllMax (Canadian brand), or Nutricost are all solid.
I personally buy most of my supplements from Nutricost on Amazon. They're budget-friendly and are a reputable source.
I absolutely love this brand and their products.
nutricost is quite decent too
I’d say the Nutricost is a dice roll, but the now is a pretty safe bet.
Parent context: Thank you so nutricost for me then. Reply: That's what I'd do, at this point. (But if I were much wealthier, then perhaps I would be interested in seeing it differently.) I do rely on nutricost for a few items.
I have so many Nutricost supplements man they’re amazing
Compare
Nutricost vs Nordic NaturalsNutricost vs NOW FoodsNutricost vs Nootropics Depot