Munchkin
Reddit take
Not enough linked mention summaries yet; the source excerpts below are the evidence.
Pros
- I grew up playing it and I still really enjoy it, so I recently dug out my old collection and realized just how many expansions I have 😂 I know it’s chaotic,random and can be pretty mean, but with the right group I think it’s a lot of...
- My early collection of games all comes from their play though! Sushi go, ticket to ride, zombie dice, tsuro, munchkin, Dixit, pandemic, takenoko, qwirkle, Carcassonne, tokaido, star realms, codenames,.
- But of course I’ll play Munchkin. It’s the perfect pub game, cos you can kind of just not pay attention and have some drinks and chat at the same time.
Cons
- To me it's so formulaic. The first person to get to the final room never wins the fight because, surprise surprise, everyone is holding something to screw them over. It's then just a case of whether everyone has enough...
- Munchkin is frequently referred to as an hour of fun in a 3 hour game.
- I don't hate it, I just find it uninteresting. It's like a long-running gag where I got the joke the first few times around and it doesn't feel like the joke is going anywhere.
- That and it routinely overstays it's welcome, where winning is less about a good play and more that everyone has simply spent all their cards stopping the last three attempts to win. Game ends up lasting an extra 30 minutes because of it...
- As a game, it’s just not good Sure the cards are funny, but the actual gameplay has so many issues The biggest one is the crabs in the bucket problem. Because everyone knows the moment you could win, they’ll do everything to stop you,...
Sentiment
3 positive (18%) · 2 mixed (12%) · 12 negative (71%)
Trust + time weighted score: -53% · raw score -53%
What redditors said (10 of 17)
To me it's so formulaic. The first person to get to the final room never wins the fight because, surprise surprise, everyone is holding something to screw them over. It's then just a case of whether everyone has enough juice left to stop the second person to get there from winning.
Munchkin is frequently referred to as an hour of fun in a 3 hour game.
I don't hate it, I just find it uninteresting. It's like a long-running gag where I got the joke the first few times around and it doesn't feel like the joke is going anywhere.
That and it routinely overstays it's welcome, where winning is less about a good play and more that everyone has simply spent all their cards stopping the last three attempts to win. Game ends up lasting an extra 30 minutes because of it, and you just want it to be over then.
As a game, it’s just not good Sure the cards are funny, but the actual gameplay has so many issues The biggest one is the crabs in the bucket problem. Because everyone knows the moment you could win, they’ll do everything to stop you, so the endgame just becomes this grind where there aren’t any real, interesting decisions Other than that it’s just a lot of luck, and, once again, not that many decisions that actually matter
Munchkin isn’t really a game of strategy or skill, it’s a game where at some point someone decides the game should be over and lets someone win.
It can be neverending and doesn’t offer meaningful choices.
I grew up playing it and I still really enjoy it, so I recently dug out my old collection and realized just how many expansions I have 😂 I know it’s chaotic,random and can be pretty mean, but with the right group I think it’s a lot of fun.
My early collection of games all comes from their play though! Sushi go, ticket to ride, zombie dice, tsuro, munchkin, Dixit, pandemic, takenoko, qwirkle, Carcassonne, tokaido, star realms, codenames,.
Hell I tried to explain munchkin to a random group of people as "like an RPG game" and was met with "what's an RPG, let's just play and see what happens,"
Compare
Munchkin vs HarmoniesMunchkin vs Sky TeamMunchkin vs Heat: Pedal to the Metal
Related
- Wingspan · related · 120 mentions
- Ra · related · 118 mentions
- Root · related · 101 mentions
- Disco Elysium · related · 99 mentions
- Catan · related · 95 mentions
- Slay the Spire · related · 91 mentions