magnesium oxide
Reddit take
AI summary of the Reddit excerpts below — not a quote
Magnesium oxide is a highly polarizing supplement, widely criticized for its poor bioavailability and significant digestive side effects, yet valued by some for its low cost and specific effectiveness. While many users dismiss it as a "cheap filler" or primarily a laxative, a minority of reviewers report it works better for their sleep and anxiety than more expensive forms like glycinate.
Pros
- Most affordable form of magnesium commonly available
- High elemental magnesium content per dose
- Effective for those specifically seeking a laxative effect or 'colon cleanse'
- Reported by some users to be superior for sleep and calming the body compared to other forms
Cons
- Frequent reports of stomach cramps, diarrhea, and digestive upset
- Widely perceived to have the lowest absorption rate (bioavailability) among magnesium types
- Often regarded as a 'waste of money' by users who saw no improvement in magnesium levels
Caveats
- Bioavailability is a major point of contention; while many cite a 4% absorption rate, others point to studies suggesting it effectively raises blood magnesium levels.
- Individual tolerance varies greatly; some experience immediate laxative effects while others use it daily without issue.
- Often used as a default ingredient in cheap multivitamins and grocery store brands.
Best for
- Budget-conscious consumers
- Occasional constipation relief
- Users who have not had success with 'gentler' forms of magnesium for sleep
Avoid if
- You have a sensitive stomach or are prone to diarrhea
- You are trying to rapidly correct a severe magnesium deficiency
- You prefer supplements with high gut-absorption rates
This summary uses balanced time weighting with about a 6-month half-life. The evidence is older (median age ~400 days), which is generally acceptable for a stable supplement, though user sentiment may not reflect the very latest brand-specific reformulations.
Sentiment
8 positive (28%) · 1 mixed (3%) · 20 negative (69%)
Trust + time weighted score: -40% · raw score -41%
What redditors said (10 of 29)
I switched back to the oxide and slept for 8 hours straight, completely undisturbed.
I believe mag oxide causes upset stomach.
Oxide is ok if you can handle the stomach upset it may cause or if you plan to use it as a "colon cleanser" you could also use it just for that.
Because your also has mag oxide, id say take it with some food and take only 1 capsule, you will probably experience some diarhea, but its not a given, you will get used to it in time, but next time dont buy oxide unless you know your stomach can handle it as you need to take quite a bit for it to get absorbed.
Magnesium glycinate is better absorbed and calming; oxide less so and can cause digestive upset.
Oxide is cheap filler that doesn't absorb well anyway.
Magnesium Oxide (cheap CVS brand) - Did absolutely nothing. Learned later the bioavailability is trash
Just make sure you get magnesium glycinate or threonate, not oxide which dosnt absorb well.
The actual data in this study shows something very different. The stated percentage of elemental magnesium absorbed from magnesium oxide in the above table — 23% — is the statistic provided in a review and meta-analysis of numerous studies by Ranade et al., (2001), cited below. ... magnesium oxide is effectively absorbed and elevates the biologically-active levels of magnesium in the bloodstream.
Parent context: It honestly is not good for me either, only oxide makes me feel genuinely great and the bad rap it gets. It is absorbing well enough and I take around 1,000mg a day. I never felt this great on glycinate! Reply: only oxide makes me feel genuinely great and the bad rap it gets.
Compare
magnesium oxide vs Nordic Naturalsmagnesium oxide vs NOW Foodsmagnesium oxide vs Nootropics Depot
Related
- magnesium glycinate · related · 134 mentions
- Creatine · related · 118 mentions
- L-Theanine · related · 96 mentions
- Ashwagandha · related · 75 mentions
- Melatonin · related · 50 mentions
- Vitamin D · related · 42 mentions