trustmebro.reviews

Goodwill

Place · Online marketplaces & resale · 31 mentions · 9 subreddits · discussed in r/Frugal, r/vinyl, r/malefashionadvice, r/AskCulinary

Reddit take

Not enough linked mention summaries yet; the source excerpts below are the evidence.

Pros

  • t's goodwill or salvation army for me , got perfectly wearable Levi jeans and many hoodies and t shirts for about a ⅓ of big box store prices.
  • Dishware and clothes can be gotten from goodwill for a couple dollars.
  • I get not wanting to go to every thrift around you and waste a ton of time but find one decent sized goodwill and check from time to time. We frequently buy our work pants there.
  • Honestly, all my suits have come from Goodwill in the US. I literally got like a $600 Italian suit for $20 there (and another $40 to have the pants taken in).
  • Goodwill will also have a large selection of cutlery. Mismatched, but entirely useful.

Cons

  • Goodwill is not what it used to be. Their prices are high, and aside from shirts/pants/jackets a lot of their stuff is cheap dollar store stuff. I have found a wonderful thrift store near me that is much larger than goodwill with a much...
  • Goodwill 👎
  • Lots of goodwill stores around me, that's where I get almost all my clothes .. just a suggestion.
  • I do not suggest Goodwill but some Salvation Armies have good prices and products.
  • GW is a for profit fake charity. Figure it out.

Sentiment

12 positive (39%) · 3 mixed (10%) · 16 negative (52%)

Trust + time weighted score: -16% · raw score -13%

What redditors said (10 of 31)

Goodwill is not what it used to be. Their prices are high, and aside from shirts/pants/jackets a lot of their stuff is cheap dollar store stuff. I have found a wonderful thrift store near me that is much larger than goodwill with a much better selection and everything is secondhand. Pants there cost $3 vs Goodwill's $8+ and the clothes are in better condition.
negative · u/S****h · r/Frugal · comment · Dec 27, 2025 · open on Reddit ↗
Goodwill 👎
negative · u/s****- · r/Frugal · comment · Dec 27, 2025 · open on Reddit ↗
t's goodwill or salvation army for me , got perfectly wearable Levi jeans and many hoodies and t shirts for about a ⅓ of big box store prices.
positive · u/S****2 · r/Frugal · comment · Dec 27, 2025 · open on Reddit ↗
Lots of goodwill stores around me, that's where I get almost all my clothes .. just a suggestion.
mixed · u/S****2 · r/Frugal · comment · Dec 27, 2025 · open on Reddit ↗
I do not suggest Goodwill but some Salvation Armies have good prices and products.
negative · u/m****e · r/Frugal · comment · Dec 3, 2025 · open on Reddit ↗
Dishware and clothes can be gotten from goodwill for a couple dollars.
positive · u/F***m · r/personalfinance · comment · Nov 24, 2025 · open on Reddit ↗
GW is a for profit fake charity. Figure it out.
negative · u/R****2 · r/vinyl · comment · Nov 24, 2025 · open on Reddit ↗
I remember clearly after Covid there was an announcement saying due to increase cost and expenses they will have to raise their prices….. then I thought, wait isn’t it just free trash people drop off. I haven’t donated to goodwill since.
negative · u/c***n · r/vinyl · comment · Nov 24, 2025 · open on Reddit ↗
Was a stack, priced $10-40 ea... For stuff that is worth $5 on a good day.
negative · u/e****s · r/vinyl · Nov 24, 2025 · open on Reddit ↗
Goodwill is especially notorious for this. ... fuck goodwill. If that’s the only store near you, find a homeless encampment and drop your clothes off there. Goodwill is pretty much a scalper at this point. They pay their employees pretty poorly, so their overhead is relatively nothing, meanwhile they get their stock for free and their prices are way too high.
negative · u/V****2 · r/Cameras · comment · Nov 13, 2025 · open on Reddit ↗

Compare

Related