Coconut Oil
Reddit take
AI summary of the Reddit excerpts below — not a quote
Coconut oil is a highly polarizing product with mixed sentiment across skincare and haircare communities. While it is valued as an effective occlusive for locking in moisture and protecting hair during washing, it is frequently criticized for being highly comedogenic (pore-clogging) and potentially making certain hair types brittle.
Pros
- Effective occlusive for sealing moisture into lips and feet
- Protects hair from protein loss and chlorine damage when used as a pre-shampoo treatment
- Contains lauric acid which can bind to hair keratin to strengthen strands
- Helps manage volume and texture for some users with very dry or coarse hair
Cons
- Highly comedogenic; frequently reported to cause breakouts and folliculitis on the face and body
- Can make hair feel brittle or 'crunchy,' similar to protein overload
- Difficult to wash out of hair and can block other products from penetrating the hair shaft
- Solidifies at room temperature (76°F), posing a significant risk for clogging household plumbing
- Can go rancid over time, leading to unpleasant odors on hair or wood surfaces
Caveats
- Always perform a patch test before skin application due to high breakout risk
- Does not polymerize, making it a poor choice for a permanent wood finish compared to drying oils
- May sit on top of the skin rather than absorbing deeply, which some users find greasy rather than moisturizing
Best for
- Pre-shampoo hair treatments
- Severely chapped lips
- Extremely dry skin on non-acne-prone areas like feet
Avoid if
- You have acne-prone or sensitive skin
- You have fine hair that is easily weighed down
- You are concerned about clogging your home's drainage pipes
This summary uses balanced time weighting with about a 6-month half-life. The evidence is older (median age ~567 days), though the biological and chemical properties of the product remain stable.
Sentiment
14 positive (38%) · 3 mixed (8%) · 20 negative (54%)
Trust + time weighted score: -20% · raw score -16%
What redditors said (10 of 37)
Coconut oil is pretty comedogenic, so it causes folliculitis in a lot of people. And coconut oil freezes (solidifies) at about 76⁰ F / 24.4⁰ C, so it can clog your home's plumbing.
I recently figured out I CANNOT use coconut oil on my body as lotion
I ran outta lotion and started using straight coconut oil instead.. bad idea.. never again..
Coconut oil melts and doesn’t seal well on its own despite occlusive properties on paper
Coconut oil as a moisturizer has anti inflammatory properties and, I’ve found, is better at penetrating chapped lips so I can move them without tugging at lip fissures and making it worse.
coconut oil is just an occlusive so it will keep moisture in the skin, but it doesn't really have any other helpful properties
Then I tried applying coconut oil for a little bit before washing it out with a shampoo (I've heard it's not good for hair health), BUT IT COMES OUT PERFECT. my hair isn't oily or dry, keeps all its volume, is not squeaky, and feels amazing.
Coconut oil broke me out as a dry skin girlie when it got all over my sheets/pillowcase after using it on my hair and elbows, so just be aware it depends on how sensitive you are!
It started becoming lighter and more brown instead of gray when I regularly used castor oil and coconut oil at night. Should I continue that? Years ago I tried using coconut oil and castor oil at night and within days I could notice the difference.
I just use the same stuff I use for my hands, which has over the years ranged from coconut oil, paula's choice body moisturizer, to lanolin based moisturizer... they all work equally fine for feet :)
Compare
Coconut Oil vs Castor OilCoconut Oil vs DIY Rice Water TonerCoconut Oil vs Centella
Related
- Tretinoin · related · 698 mentions
- Azelaic Acid · related · 504 mentions
- CeraVe Moisturizer · related · 334 mentions
- Adapalene · related · 313 mentions
- Aquaphor · related · 268 mentions
- Vaseline · related · 250 mentions