CellarTracker
Reddit take
Not enough linked mention summaries yet; the source excerpts below are the evidence.
Pros
- But I also have Cellartracker, and that's where I'll note the Buy Again and Nope! and "hmmm, good price for a party"
- Cellar tracker is excellent as the tasting notes are often the most up to date
- cellatracker. Not perfect but for obscure bottles you can see how recent tastings have fared
- I just checked on my cellartracker app. I have registered but not paid anything. I can still add wines to my cellar and remove them.
- Parent context: I thought you had to pay for cellar tracker in function of how many bottles you have in your cellar? Reply: [There doesn't seem to be any limit to the size of your cellar on the free tier](https://share.google/kcXuSCAjKtU...
Cons
- Probably cellertracker, if you must. Saying that, is it such a big problem for you? I imagine it can be useful if you have a few cases of a specific wine, but for a few bottles, bad luck and someone else's palette are probably not much h...
- Parent context: If it were both men and women it might be tolerable, but women-only is definitely a bit creeper. Of course it’s nothing compared to other bonkers tasting notes I’ve read, there’s some guy on CT named BellevuePhil th...
- Yeah, this is pretty similar to my experience of CT. I also regularly buy wines that are not in the database and have never figured out how to add new wines. It is really suboptimal that some of your wines are missing from My Cellar.
- "Best" people keep mentioning CT as some form of superior place for reviews when it relativly speaking more or less has the same volume of usless reviews. As well as the userbase being heavily Bdx/Napa biased. Sure if you want reviews on...
Sentiment
16 positive (80%) · 2 mixed (10%) · 2 negative (10%)
Trust + time weighted score: +69% · raw score 70%
What redditors said (10 of 20)
But I also have Cellartracker, and that's where I'll note the Buy Again and Nope! and "hmmm, good price for a party"
Probably cellertracker, if you must. Saying that, is it such a big problem for you? I imagine it can be useful if you have a few cases of a specific wine, but for a few bottles, bad luck and someone else's palette are probably not much help.
Cellar tracker is excellent as the tasting notes are often the most up to date
cellatracker. Not perfect but for obscure bottles you can see how recent tastings have fared
I just checked on my cellartracker app. I have registered but not paid anything. I can still add wines to my cellar and remove them.
Parent context: I thought you had to pay for cellar tracker in function of how many bottles you have in your cellar? Reply: [There doesn't seem to be any limit to the size of your cellar on the free tier](https://share.google/kcXuSCAjKtUlzWnRa). Their pricing model does suggest that they'd like you to pay more if you have a larger cellar, but you can select the minimum amount without any loss of features on the premium plan (which is what I do).
Cellartracker is still free for adding wines to your cellar, so you could use that.
Parent context: If it were both men and women it might be tolerable, but women-only is definitely a bit creeper. Of course it’s nothing compared to other bonkers tasting notes I’ve read, there’s some guy on CT named BellevuePhil that compares every wine he tastes to a different woman he claims to have bedded. Reply: [Read it yourself](https://www.cellartracker.com/list.asp?Table=Notes&iUserOverride=826399), it's like wine tasting notes plus bad erotic fanfic
It is always informative to read CellarTracker reviews. Individual ones may be a bit eccentric but in the aggregate they are surprisingly useful.
I cross reference with CellarTracker to work out whether I’m looking at good value or a dud.
Compare
CellarTracker vs God of PromptCellarTracker vs StockfishCellarTracker vs Backblaze
Related
- Vivino · related · 35 mentions
- Josh.ai · related · 14 mentions
- WineBid · related · 12 mentions
- The Wine Society · related · 10 mentions