Side by side
Sennheiser PC38X vs Astro A50 Gen 5
Sennheiser PC38X
88 positive (72%) · 21 mixed (17%) · 13 negative (11%)
Trust + time weighted: +58%
AI summary — not a quote
The Sennheiser PC38X is widely regarded by the Reddit community as one of the best all-in-one wired gaming headsets, frequently recommended over traditional 'gaming' brands for its superior imaging and natural tuning. While it excels in competitive FPS titles due to its open-back design and accurate sound localization, users often debate its value compared to the Sennheiser HD560S, which some find better for music. Common criticisms focus on its plasticky build, high clamping force, and potential long-term issues with the flip-to-mute microphone mechanism.
Pros
- Excellent directional audio and imaging for competitive FPS gaming
- High-quality built-in microphone compared to most gaming headsets
- Easy to drive via console controllers or PC without an external amp
- Natural, well-balanced tuning that works well for both games and music
Cons
- Build feels 'plasticky' and can be prone to creaking
- Flip-to-mute microphone mechanism may become unreliable over time
- High clamping force and shallow/narrow ear pads can cause discomfort
- Open-back design offers zero noise isolation and leaks sound to others
Top excerpts
They come from Sennheiser, so an actual respected headphone manufacturer rather than "gaming" brands, and are often referred to as the best wired gaming headset on the market.
I'm looking for audiophile headphones for gaming (open world, single player story driven and multiplayer) that sound better than PC38x (my current headset)
PC38x is just a worse HD560s but with a mic.
If you're talking FPS, you could try the DROP PC38X. They were developed with Sennheiser's then communication division.
560S are solid all around including gaming. Most things are better than 990. 38X is a little better for gaming in *some* ways but not enough to justify the switch imo, and 560S is better for music.
Astro A50 Gen 5
12 positive (92%) · 1 mixed (8%) · 0 negative (0%)
Trust + time weighted: +87%
Top excerpts
I despise having to have a base station but obviously no getting around it with the a50.
A50. Sound great, not as immersive, but I have a blast on BF6, which whist is a FPS game, the audio design is still immense with the A50. The Mic is exceptional for a wireless headset mic. The battery is fantastic. The build quality is great (there’s a reason people still have their Astro a40’s). The wireless charging is great.
The A50’s whilst having smaller cups (I feel my ears very occasionally touching the pads), are much lighter, and I can wear them for absolute hours.
i really like the base for the a50. i think it even brings a charm to the setup.
The a50s seems more convinient, more comfortable, better mic, and its acutally cheaper - around $229 in walmart and maxwells are around $280-300.