Side by side
Old Forester 1924 vs Wild Turkey Rare Breed
Old Forester 1924
78 positive (84%) · 14 mixed (15%) · 1 negative (1%)
Trust + time weighted: +83%
AI summary — not a quote
Old Forester 1924 is a 10-year-old addition to the Whiskey Row series that is highly regarded for its flavor profile but frequently criticized for its premium price point. Enthusiasts often describe it as a "Baby Birthday Bourbon," offering a complex, chocolate and dark cherry-forward experience at 100 proof. While the liquid quality is consistently praised, a significant portion of the community finds it difficult to justify the ~$100+ MSRP when other well-regarded Whiskey Row bottles like 1910 and 1920 are available for nearly half the price.
Pros
- Complex flavor profile featuring notes of chocolate, dark cherry, leather, and polished oak.
- Often compared favorably to the highly elusive Birthday Bourbon in terms of character.
- Excellent sipping experience for a 100-proof whiskey, showing significant aged character.
- Generally preferred by enthusiasts over other 10-year competitors like Jack Daniel's 10-Year.
Cons
- High MSRP (often $100-$115) is a major deterrent for value-conscious buyers.
- The 100 proof may feel underpowered for drinkers who prefer barrel-strength or high-proof expressions.
- Some users noted the body can feel slightly thin despite the complex flavors.
Top excerpts
5.7 | Good | Good, just fine Old Forester 1924 (5.7)
1924 is on its own level - all love, solid 7.5 from me. $99 from Costco - it was a must try based on the reviews here. It didn't disappoint as I veer towards to the sweet end of bourbons in general.
This bottle rocks. I do wish it was either cask strength OR high proof (similar to 1920). Feel like it would be stellar without being watered down; mouthfeel, finish, some more oak.
Catching 1924 at Costco for $100 is a steal, that price makes it a no-brainer over 1920 in my book.
I was overwhelmed by the red fruits you mention on the palate. I thought it was a flavorful, easy sipper. I tend to like higher proof bourbons but this seems to drink a bit higher than its proof. I love it. The nose is incredible and the flavor matches the nose for me.
Wild Turkey Rare Breed
31 positive (91%) · 3 mixed (9%) · 0 negative (0%)
Trust + time weighted: +94%
AI summary — not a quote
Wild Turkey Rare Breed is widely considered a gold standard for value-to-performance in the bourbon community. It is frequently cited as a top-tier barrel-proof offering that remains accessible and affordable, often outperforming significantly more expensive or allocated bottles in blind tastings and daily use.
Pros
- Exceptional value for a barrel-proof bourbon
- High complexity with a rich, multi-layered flavor profile
- Widely available and easy to find compared to other high-proof competitors
- Versatile enough to be enjoyed neat or as a high-end cocktail base
Cons
- High proof can be perceived as harsh or unbalanced by some drinkers
- Regional price fluctuations can occasionally push it out of the 'budget' category
Top excerpts
But I’d also take Wild Turkey Rare Breed over all of them for $45.
Is it a world beater? No. Is it respectable whiskey at a great price and always consistent? Yes.
I thank my lucky stars that WT puts out a Barrell proof bourbon like they have it on tap. Always available, consistently good, and reasonably priced.
Local has for 40 as well. Such a fantastic bottle.
Guesses and ratings: Rare Breed glass 1, 7.5; Saffell glas 2, 6.5. Reveal: glass 1 is, surprise surprise, Rare Breed, glass 2 is Saffell. Thoughts: this was more clear-cut than I expected. I also affirmed my original conclusions on Saffell: its hard to justify a $50 375ml bottle when RB is better and is half the cost.