Side by side
Immich vs Proxmox
Immich
27 positive (93%) · 2 mixed (7%) · 0 negative (0%)
Trust + time weighted: +95%
Top excerpts
I switched to Immich at the weekend. ... Works so incredibly well I'm actually kinda shocked.
I used Immich for my software.
Parent context: I'm curious, what AI processing are you doing on the images? Reply: Immich has some built in ML tools like face recognition, I'm guessing that
Parent context: That's really unfortunate... I wanted to present my ppen source portfolio photography software that is targeted to photographers on which I have been working since 2018... (So NOT the vibe coding thing we see popping left and right). An alternative to Pixeset, Immich etc... I guess I missed the "window of opportunity." :( Reply: It's unfortunate, but we're getting 2 or 3 projects/day trying to promote themselves and there's just not room on the subreddit for that :(
Google photos --> immich
Proxmox
80 positive (75%) · 21 mixed (20%) · 6 negative (6%)
Trust + time weighted: +68%
AI summary — not a quote
Proxmox is a highly regarded open-source virtualization platform, widely praised for its ability to repurpose older hardware into functional servers. It is frequently cited as a top alternative to enterprise solutions like VMware and Hyper-V, offering a Debian-based environment with a native web-based UI for managing virtual machines and containers. While it is a staple in the homelab community, professional sentiment is mixed regarding its readiness for large-scale corporate environments compared to established competitors.
Pros
- Excellent for repurposing older hardware (e.g., Optiplex, mini PCs) into capable servers.
- Comprehensive, well-organized native web UI for management.
- Flexible Debian-based architecture allows for a wide variety of VM and container use cases.
- Strong community recommendation as a viable migration path from VMware or Hyper-V.
Cons
- Virtual machines are often blocked by aggressive e-sports anti-cheat systems (e.g., Valorant, Rainbow 6 Siege).
- Multi-cluster management tools are considered less mature than enterprise alternatives like vCenter.
- Some users find the interface and workflow unintuitive or lacking a 'corporate' feel.
- Documentation is sometimes viewed as less intuitive compared to competitors like TrueNAS Scale.
Top excerpts
All of those features are built into Proxmox, with a clear and well organised UI, natively. Why forsake them?
Mommy gon be mad when she finds out her "Windows Home Server" is running Proxmox now.
Mini Server running ProxMox (AdGuard, Tailscale, A.R.M.)
Turned all my old parts into a server. Runs on proxmox and does all my video and music streaming now. Requires a bit of investment but it's been so worth it compared to the services I had been using.
Proxmox has a few more configuration options and management access aswell as performing a bit better. Truenas scale has a better ui, more intuitive monitoring and settings and (imo) better documentation. In normal use cases theres nothing proxmox does that truenas cant, so if you have a working setup, just stick to it.