Side by side

Appleton Estate 12 Year Old Jamaican Rum vs Plymouth Gin

Appleton Estate 12 Year Old Jamaican Rum (11 mentions) vs Plymouth Gin (10 mentions): verbatim Reddit excerpts, sentiment split and trust-weighted score side by side.

Appleton Estate 12 Year Old Jamaican Rum

Gin, vodka, rum, tequila & other spirits · 11 mentions · 1 subreddit · #1 of 15 in Gin, vodka, rum, tequila & other spirits

11 positive (100%) · 0 mixed (0%) · 0 negative (0%)

Trust + time weighted: +100%

Top excerpts

*2:1:1 Appleton 12, Smith & Cross, Worthy Park 109.

positive · u/C****n · r/cocktails · Aug 30, 2025 · open on Reddit ↗

Then yeah for aged I think Appleton Signature, 8, or 12 or El dorado 8 or 12 would be great choices and work great in a Mai tai.

positive · u/d***y · r/cocktails · comment · Jul 29, 2025 · open on Reddit ↗

Combined the most expensive rum I owned (Appleton 12) with the cheapest (Cruzan blackstrap)!

positive · u/M****3 · r/cocktails · comment · Jul 20, 2025 · open on Reddit ↗

I love Appleton 12.

positive · u/l****d · r/cocktails · comment · Jul 20, 2025 · open on Reddit ↗

Appleton 12 is yummy.

positive · u/l****d · r/cocktails · comment · Jul 20, 2025 · open on Reddit ↗

Plymouth Gin

Gin, vodka, rum, tequila & other spirits · 10 mentions · 1 subreddit · #5 of 15 in Gin, vodka, rum, tequila & other spirits

9 positive (90%) · 1 mixed (10%) · 0 negative (0%)

Trust + time weighted: +91%

Top excerpts

Parent context: Have you noticed a flavor difference since they dropped the proof to 80? Reply: Yes, 44% was perfect for a Negroni. I’m done buying Beefeater forever, Plymouth is my go to now.

positive · u/o****s · r/cocktails · comment · Feb 9, 2025 · open on Reddit ↗

Plymouth!

positive · u/Y****t · r/cocktails · comment · Dec 11, 2025 · open on Reddit ↗

I've enjoyed Plymouth, Tanq10, Ford's, Sipsmith, and Broker's, among others.

positive · u/C****n · r/cocktails · comment · Dec 10, 2025 · open on Reddit ↗

You'll also want a standard London Dry gin. Plymouth or Sipsmith are great options.

positive · u/d****y · r/cocktails · comment · Nov 3, 2025 · open on Reddit ↗

Plymouth is Juniper heavy

mixed · u/B****6 · r/cocktails · comment · Jul 27, 2025 · open on Reddit ↗