Thursday Boots
Reddit take
AI summary of the Reddit excerpts below — not a quote
Thursday Boots is widely considered the primary "entry-level" brand for those transitioning from sneakers to Goodyear-welted footwear. While frequently praised for their $200 price point, modern aesthetics, and out-of-the-box comfort, they are a polarizing topic among enthusiasts. Critics often point to mediocre leather selection, inconsistent quality control, and construction that prioritizes cost-savings over the high-end heritage standards found in more expensive brands.
Pros
- High value-to-price ratio for the $200 market
- Comfortable out-of-the-box feel due to foam-integrated insoles
- Stylish designs that frequently garner compliments
- Responsive customer service, including quick refunds or replacements for defects
- Resolable construction, making them a more sustainable choice than fashion brands
Cons
- Inconsistent quality control, with reports of sole delamination and shipping errors
- Lower-tier leather selection that may crease more aggressively than premium hides
- Construction lacks the "heft" and traditional full-leather feel of higher-end heritage boots
- Mixed durability reports, with some users experiencing significant wear within a year
Caveats
- Enthusiasts in specialized communities often view the brand as 'mediocre' compared to $400+ options like Grant Stone or Alden
- The use of foam in the insole provides immediate comfort but is sometimes viewed as a shortcut compared to traditional cork and leather
Best for
- First-time boot buyers on a budget
- Transitioning from sneakers to leather footwear
- Casual office environments and urban wear
Avoid if
- You are looking for top-tier leather hide quality and selection
- You want a heavy-duty 'Buy It For Life' work boot for labor-intensive tasks
- You prefer traditional, firm all-leather construction
This summary uses balanced time weighting with about a 18-month half-life. The evidence is drawn from a consistent stream of mentions across 2025, providing a current view of the brand's reputation.
Sentiment
26 positive (46%) · 15 mixed (26%) · 16 negative (28%)
Trust + time weighted score: +19% · raw score 18%
What redditors said (10 of 57)
Most people want options for their individual outfits, and in that way Thursday is definitely filling a niche with a quality boot.
Thursday continues to make a great boot at their price point, for sure.
The interior of the boot is lined with a leather and foam insole. It feels not as firm as a full leather insole, but not as soft as something like Thursdays.
dark brown chukka or Chelsea boots from AE, Grant Stone, or Thursday Boots.
I have or have trialed chelsea boots from Carmina, Meermin, Canada West, Jim Green, and Thursday
I’m also gonna do a little bit of a comparison to Thursday boots, of which I am overall disappointed.
Thursday is always a good first step. Most of their models are built with comfort in mind, so they'll be a much easier transition from sneakers to leather shoes. They're well priced, easy returns, resolable, and well made.
Black Oxford, brown Oxford or derby (maybe brogue) and brown derby boot or loafer - Alden, allen Edmonds on sale are still decent, Thursdays on a budget, or Beckett Simonon all work.
I bought a new pair of Thursday for my sister this year and the Leather looks the same as it did 6 years since I’ve my first pair
other options from Thursday, Allen Edmonds, and C&J exist if you need to move up or down the price tier.
Compare
Thursday Boots vs Nicks BootsThursday Boots vs Beckett SimononThursday Boots vs Grant Stone