trustmebro.reviews

The Magicians (TV series)

Media Title · TV series · 19 mentions · 7 subreddits · discussed in r/televisionsuggestions, r/Fantasy, r/MovieSuggestions, r/books

Reddit take

Not enough linked mention summaries yet; the source excerpts below are the evidence.

Pros

  • I found The Magicians in a thrift store. I hadn't heard anything about it or the TV series before. I loved it.
  • All those shows have been solid, so I have some excitement that he can handle the show and keep it going on a great path.
  • The Magicians
  • It’s a show not movie but The Magicians hits this vibe really well. It’s dark and about flawed (low key really fucked up) 20 somethings dealing with the most dark themes of being human. It is fantasy and magic focused, but honestly it ju...
  • I'm going to give you some examples of the types of supernatural shows that really enjoy: witches of east end, the magicians, charmed, bitten.

Cons

  • I know one of the other big names in the subgenre is The Magicians, and while I haven't read it, I did watch the first season of the show and it didn't pique my interest
  • Yeah my main issue with the magicians is that it felt like it was trying WAY too hard to be the edgy Narnia/Harry Potter (which in theory sounds cool but it leaned into those narratives too hard) plus the characters were just really hard...
  • Unpopular opinion but I really disliked the magicians so it’s kind of turned me off of Lev Grossman
  • Books that were meh / I did *not* like: ... The Magicians
  • Probably not your thing, but maybe The Magicians. The first few episodes are not representative of the series as a whole. Another love it or hate it series.

Sentiment

14 positive (74%) · 1 mixed (5%) · 4 negative (21%)

Trust + time weighted score: +55% · raw score 53%

What redditors said (10 of 19)

I found The Magicians in a thrift store. I hadn't heard anything about it or the TV series before. I loved it.
positive · u/Q****y · r/books · comment · Jan 16, 2025 · open on Reddit ↗
I know one of the other big names in the subgenre is The Magicians, and while I haven't read it, I did watch the first season of the show and it didn't pique my interest
negative · u/D***W · r/Fantasy · Dec 21, 2025 · open on Reddit ↗
All those shows have been solid, so I have some excitement that he can handle the show and keep it going on a great path.
positive · u/A****n · r/television · comment · Nov 18, 2025 · open on Reddit ↗
The Magicians
positive · u/V****9 · r/televisionsuggestions · comment · Nov 15, 2025 · open on Reddit ↗
It’s a show not movie but The Magicians hits this vibe really well. It’s dark and about flawed (low key really fucked up) 20 somethings dealing with the most dark themes of being human. It is fantasy and magic focused, but honestly it just allows them to go even darker and create more dynamic character growth. It’s great commentary on the world we live in and the human condition.
positive · u/K****r · r/MovieSuggestions · comment · Nov 9, 2025 · open on Reddit ↗
I'm going to give you some examples of the types of supernatural shows that really enjoy: witches of east end, the magicians, charmed, bitten.
positive · u/i****g · r/televisionsuggestions · Nov 9, 2025 · open on Reddit ↗
The magicians
positive · u/B****4 · r/MovieSuggestions · comment · Aug 17, 2025 · open on Reddit ↗
You see all the characters dealing with everything from PTSD to suicide and addiction. The magic in the show is both real and a metaphor for self-medicating.
positive · u/o****a · r/televisionsuggestions · comment · Aug 14, 2025 · open on Reddit ↗
If I had to pick just one show from this list it'll be The Magicians, it's just entertaining all around.
positive · u/R****4 · r/televisionsuggestions · comment · Jul 23, 2025 · open on Reddit ↗
If I had to pick just one show from this list it'll be The Magicians, it's just entertaining all around.
positive · u/R****4 · r/televisionsuggestions · comment · Jul 17, 2025 · open on Reddit ↗

Compare

Related