trustmebro.reviews

The Fifth Season

Book · Fantasy books · 31 mentions · 4 subreddits · discussed in r/Fantasy, r/suggestmeabook, r/BookRecommendations, r/horrorlit

Reddit take

Not enough linked mention summaries yet; the source excerpts below are the evidence.

Pros

  • Some of my other favorite books or series for perspective: Wheel of Time, Song of Ice & Fire, Lord of the Rings, World of the Five Gods, Lymond Chronicles(not fantasy, but feels like it and just plain awesome), The Fifth Season, and Real...
  • If you want excellent fantasy, you could also get your F by reading The Fifth Season by NK Jemisin.
  • In this eerie post-apocalyptic masterpiece, the setting is a planet devastated by earthquakes, where magic users with the ability to control seismic events are terrorised.
  • Parent context: Just finished "The Fifth Season" by N. K. Jemisin, and I feel thoroughly disappointed. ... (don't even wanna talk about those second person portions, omg why?) Reply: Yeah I am usually the first to loathe second person bu...
  • I thought The Fifth Season was very creative and atmospheric, way more immersive than books usually are, due to the great and unique writing.

Cons

  • From the infodumping at the beginning to the clumsy ending, the writing feels more than a bit amateurish. (don't even wanna talk about those second person portions, omg why?) The world building which should be immersive, does the opposit...
  • This is a great series, but I would say it is heavily focused on trauma and while it’s not explicitly trauma from being a person of color, that metaphor is extremely strong. So it might not fit what OP is looking for if they want somethi...
  • Examples of this can be seen in the X-Men, Dragon Age, The Fifth Season etc.

Sentiment

28 positive (90%) · 2 mixed (6%) · 1 negative (3%)

Trust + time weighted score: +87% · raw score 87%

What redditors said (10 of 31)

Some of my other favorite books or series for perspective: Wheel of Time, Song of Ice & Fire, Lord of the Rings, World of the Five Gods, Lymond Chronicles(not fantasy, but feels like it and just plain awesome), The Fifth Season, and Realm of the Elderlings.
positive · u/M****T · r/Fantasy · Dec 7, 2025 · open on Reddit ↗
If you want excellent fantasy, you could also get your F by reading The Fifth Season by NK Jemisin.
positive · u/S****h · r/suggestmeabook · comment · Aug 20, 2026 · open on Reddit ↗
In this eerie post-apocalyptic masterpiece, the setting is a planet devastated by earthquakes, where magic users with the ability to control seismic events are terrorised.
positive · u/k****p · r/Fantasy · Aug 7, 2026 · open on Reddit ↗
Parent context: Just finished "The Fifth Season" by N. K. Jemisin, and I feel thoroughly disappointed. ... (don't even wanna talk about those second person portions, omg why?) Reply: Yeah I am usually the first to loathe second person but I was able to read this one and I told everyone (before I finished it) that it felt like the narrator was talking to "you" and not me, the reader). I felt so vindicated at the end.
positive · u/_****e · r/Fantasy · comment · Aug 6, 2026 · open on Reddit ↗
I thought The Fifth Season was very creative and atmospheric, way more immersive than books usually are, due to the great and unique writing.
positive · u/p****y · r/Fantasy · comment · Aug 6, 2026 · open on Reddit ↗
It was one of the first books I've read in a long time that felt like it was written for adults who could handle nuance and appreciate stylistic prose. ... It was so refreshing to find a new-to-me author who treated her readers like adults :')
positive · u/s****s · r/Fantasy · comment · Aug 6, 2026 · open on Reddit ↗
I think the trilogy is a masterpiece and the writing is extremely intentional and skillfully done.
positive · u/n****e · r/Fantasy · comment · Aug 6, 2026 · open on Reddit ↗
But since finishing it, it’s a series that has surprisingly stuck with me. I find myself thinking back to some of its themes
positive · u/G****m · r/Fantasy · comment · Aug 6, 2026 · open on Reddit ↗
From the infodumping at the beginning to the clumsy ending, the writing feels more than a bit amateurish. (don't even wanna talk about those second person portions, omg why?) The world building which should be immersive, does the opposite; the plot is nonexistent, the twists were there, and the cliffhanger was abrupt.
negative · u/S****a · r/Fantasy · Aug 6, 2026 · open on Reddit ↗
I'm already in the middle of some of these like The Fifth Season (around a hundred pages in)... and I do enjoy them (esp Liveship and the Fifth Season)
positive · u/I****3 · r/Fantasy · Jul 24, 2026 · open on Reddit ↗

Compare

Related