SnapRAID
Reddit take
Not enough linked mention summaries yet; the source excerpts below are the evidence.
Pros
- had 10x 3.5" HDDs across two 5-bay USB 3.0 enclosures which worked fine with DrivePool and Snapraid... Went with Windows 11 IoT LTSC (non-bloated and solid version, highly recommend it) with good old DrivePool and Snapraid
- Went with Windows 11 IoT LTSC (non-bloated and solid version, highly recommend it) with good old DrivePool and Snapraid as it's basically for Torrent and PleX/Jellyfin.
- i recommend using Mergerfs for the drivepool and Snapraid as a disk failure backup and recovery solution.
- I looked into it, snapraid seems like it would be good for me.
- unraid and snapraid both work will with mix drives.
Cons
- The only thing to keep in mind though is that SnapRAID does not have realtime parity and instead depends on a scheduled sync operation, so is not suitable for often changing files. it does however provide actual bitrot detection/correcti...
- If you don't like truenas you could still run full freebsd or Linux and have a lot more options but still run zfs underneath or btrfs, mergerfs and snapraid however you want.
- I also plan to add snapRaid to my mergerFS Pool, but for now Im thinking about how to extend my backup space as my backup disk is getting full.
- It is paid though, and there are other options but nothing I can speak for (I believe snapraid is similar).
- Remember that while snapraid does provide redundancy using parity, it is not real time. In some ways this is great, in other ways bad. Great: It allows you to use the parity to restore stuff you deleted by mistake. Bad: You need to man...
Sentiment
31 positive (74%) · 9 mixed (21%) · 2 negative (5%)
Trust + time weighted score: +71% · raw score 69%
What redditors said (10 of 42)
had 10x 3.5" HDDs across two 5-bay USB 3.0 enclosures which worked fine with DrivePool and Snapraid... Went with Windows 11 IoT LTSC (non-bloated and solid version, highly recommend it) with good old DrivePool and Snapraid
Went with Windows 11 IoT LTSC (non-bloated and solid version, highly recommend it) with good old DrivePool and Snapraid as it's basically for Torrent and PleX/Jellyfin.
i recommend using Mergerfs for the drivepool and Snapraid as a disk failure backup and recovery solution.
I looked into it, snapraid seems like it would be good for me.
unraid and snapraid both work will with mix drives.
The only thing to keep in mind though is that SnapRAID does not have realtime parity and instead depends on a scheduled sync operation, so is not suitable for often changing files. it does however provide actual bitrot detection/correction unlike Unraid's array.
Snapraid and MergerFS will be your goto
snapraid w/mergerfs fits exactly my needs. I spin my disks down at night which may even extend their lifespan (who knows) anyway, I'd run a Linux distro of choice, or if you want to slice and dice obviously proxmox is a valid choice, then fire up a docker host (Debian person myself) and docker away setup a nightly snapraid scrub and sync, can support as many disk failures as you'd like.
the long term was important to me which is why I went with MergerFS + SnapRAID.
Look into SnapRaid if you want to go the economical USB route.
Compare
SnapRAID vs TailscaleSnapRAID vs Home AssistantSnapRAID vs ZFS