Slewfoot
Reddit take
AI summary of the Reddit excerpts below — not a quote
Slewfoot is a highly regarded historical horror-fantasy novel set in colonial America, frequently praised for its atmospheric "witchy vibes" and integration of Pagan folklore against a backdrop of Puritan extremism. While the majority of readers celebrate its blend of whimsical, enchanting, and dark emotional themes, a minority of critics find the story leans too heavily into dark fantasy or romance elements rather than pure horror.
Pros
- Strong atmospheric "witchy vibes" and historical colonial setting
- Engaging use of supernatural elements and religious folklore
- High-quality internal artwork by the author
- Excellent audiobook narration with distinct character voices
- Satisfying ending that many readers consider the best part of the book
Cons
- Genre shift from creepy/unsettling to dark fantasy romance may disappoint horror purists
- Some readers find the tone to be slightly "twee"
- Occasional preference for Brom's art over his prose
Caveats
- The book dances the line between whimsical enchantment and heavy horror, which may not fit everyone's definition of the horror genre.
- The middle section of the book is noted by some to shift significantly in tone from the beginning.
Best for
- Fans of folk horror and historical fiction
- Readers who enjoy witch-centric stories and Pagan themes
- Those who appreciate books with integrated illustrations
- Audiobook listeners looking for strong voice performances
Avoid if
- You are looking for a strictly terrifying horror novel without fantasy elements
- You dislike romantic subplots in your dark fiction
- You prefer fast-paced horror over atmospheric historical builds
This summary uses balanced time weighting with about a 122-month half-life. The evidence is drawn from a consistent pool of mentions in horror-focused communities with a median source age of approximately 406 days.
Sentiment
67 positive (75%) · 11 mixed (12%) · 11 negative (12%)
Trust + time weighted score: +62% · raw score 63%
What redditors said (10 of 89)
Also came to say Slewfoot!
Slewfoot - Loved the witchy vibes, but the fantasy elements are not for me.
I recently finished Slewfoot by Brom and really enjoyed it.
Slewfoot. It's a terrific seasonal autumnal vibe with a fascinating take on early American witches
Parent context: Slewfoot. It's a terrific seasonal autumnal vibe with a fascinating take on early American witches Reply: My book club did this for our October meeting last year and it went over incredibly well. Only a few of us like and regularly read horror, but almost everyone enjoyed this book.
Slewfoot by Brom is a 5 star read (in my opinion), highly recommend
I just wanted to comment about Slewfoot, and I'm so glad someone thinks the same about Slewfoot. It was VERY underwhelming.
please don't recommend Slewfoot, I have read it and it was underwhelming
Slewfoot was done very very well by the narrator. Different voices and the way she read really had me engaged.
I think Slewfoot by Brohm qualifies.
Compare
Slewfoot vs Dark MatterSlewfoot vs MiserySlewfoot vs Books of Blood
Related
- Dungeon Crawler Carl · related · 434 mentions
- Project Hail Mary · related · 325 mentions
- Between Two Fires · related · 239 mentions
- The Wheel of Time · related · 222 mentions
- Piranesi · related · 210 mentions
- House of Leaves · related · 204 mentions