Scythe (Neal Shusterman)

Pros

• Exceptional art and production quality in the board game version
• Smooth and fast-paced turns that facilitate satisfying engine building
• Compelling dystopian world-building in the Neal Shusterman book series
• Effective 'Cold War' simulation where the threat of conflict creates constant tension
• Expansions like 'The Wind Gambit' successfully add variety to endgame conditions

Cons

• Board game combat can feel underwhelming or 'light' compared to its economic systems
• Fixed starting positions can lead to 'rote' openings and repetitive gameplay for experienced players
• High price point for the board game relative to some users' enjoyment
• Certain faction and board pairings are perceived as unbalanced or 'broken' in competitive play

Caveats

• The board game is often mistaken for a combat-heavy war game due to its miniatures, but it is primarily an economic euro-style game
• Once mastered, the board game can shift from a fun puzzle to a rigid 'build order' exercise where the first 16 turns are pre-planned
• Some users find the gameplay 'plodding' or 'unfocused' due to the mix of exploration, resource gathering, and combat

Best for

• Board gamers who prioritize resource management and high-quality components
• Fans of young adult dystopian fiction looking for a 'brilliant' series
• Players who enjoy engine building with a focus on efficiency over direct aggression

Avoid if

• You are looking for a high-conflict, combat-centric 'dudes on a map' war game
• You dislike games where optimal strategies can become scripted after repeated plays