Replica by the Fireplace
Reddit take
Not enough linked mention summaries yet; the source excerpts below are the evidence.
Pros
- Another blind buy for me was Replica By The Fireplace, again can be fairly controversial but I knew that it’ll be the one for me and I was right. Loved it so much that I ordered a 100 ml refill the same day I received my 30 ml bottle in...
- Eg By the Fireplace lasts quite a bit
- Parent context: Probably smells similar to replica by the fireplace place. Burning wood and burning leaves. I like that smell but not on my physical person and not if there is an actual fire coming close to the house. 😁 Reply: See, I fi...
- a couple of perfumes they’ve worn/enjoyed are: replica’s by the fireplace, jhag not a perfume, and glossier you.
- CVS frequently has Replica for 75% off. I saw By the Fireplace yesterday, at my CVS, for $27.
Cons
- ALL for it to smell like Smokey play doh on your skin (me with replica by the fireplace)😞😞🥲
- I scoured Reddit to find posts on cold weather scents and got samples of all the most repeated answers: D&G The One, TF Tobacco Vanilla, TF Noir Extreme, Replica: Jazz Club, and Replica: By the Fireplace. Jazz Club was ok, but I hated a...
- Kind of reminds me of replica by the fireplace but less Smokey and more vanilla..
Sentiment
7 positive (70%) · 1 mixed (10%) · 2 negative (20%)
Trust + time weighted score: +48% · raw score 50%
What redditors said (10 of 10)
ALL for it to smell like Smokey play doh on your skin (me with replica by the fireplace)😞😞🥲
Another blind buy for me was Replica By The Fireplace, again can be fairly controversial but I knew that it’ll be the one for me and I was right. Loved it so much that I ordered a 100 ml refill the same day I received my 30 ml bottle in the post.
Eg By the Fireplace lasts quite a bit
I scoured Reddit to find posts on cold weather scents and got samples of all the most repeated answers: D&G The One, TF Tobacco Vanilla, TF Noir Extreme, Replica: Jazz Club, and Replica: By the Fireplace. Jazz Club was ok, but I hated all the rest.
Parent context: Probably smells similar to replica by the fireplace place. Burning wood and burning leaves. I like that smell but not on my physical person and not if there is an actual fire coming close to the house. 😁 Reply: See, I find by the fireplace very pleasant! Smoky in a cozy way.
a couple of perfumes they’ve worn/enjoyed are: replica’s by the fireplace, jhag not a perfume, and glossier you.
CVS frequently has Replica for 75% off. I saw By the Fireplace yesterday, at my CVS, for $27.
In case it helps, I've liked Kilian Princess (but it fades immediately), Steamed Rainbow, Guerlain tobacco and honey, Replica By The Fireplace (fades quickly though), Phlur Heavy Cream and Strawberry Letter.
Replica By The Fireplace. Moderate sillage and longevity. Definitely could smell the spices and especially the vanilla. It's cold weather here and I was outdoors all day, would love to smell it inside a warm room with a fire!
Kind of reminds me of replica by the fireplace but less Smokey and more vanilla..
Compare
Replica by the Fireplace vs ParfumoReplica by the Fireplace vs Burberry GoddessReplica by the Fireplace vs Tabac
Related
- By the Fireplace · parent · 40 mentions
- Burberry Goddess · related · 81 mentions
- Glossier You · related · 71 mentions
- Black Opium · related · 70 mentions
- Bianco Latte · related · 66 mentions
- Shalimar · related · 65 mentions
- Le Labo Another 13 · related · 64 mentions