Horizon Zero Dawn

Pros

• Satisfying and rewarding combat, particularly when taking down large machines solo
• Engaging plot development with a slow, mesmerising reveal of the world's mystery
• Rich lore and world-building that encourages exploration and reading
• Straightforward and action-focused mechanics with a no-nonsense skill tree
• Exceptional visual design and art direction

Cons

• Traversal and climbing can feel unengaging, often reduced to finding highlighted handholds
• Melee combat is often viewed as secondary or underpowered compared to ranged options
• Gyro aiming implementation is criticized as feeling 'wrong' even after adjustment
• The board game adaptation is criticized as a 'cash grab' focused on expensive plastic miniatures

Caveats

• Opinions are mixed on the open-world depth, with some describing it as 'wide as an ocean, deep as a puddle'
• The game follows a formula similar to other open-world titles like the Batman Arkham series or Spider-Man, which may feel repetitive to some
• There is a notable sentiment that the original game is more focused and enjoyable than its sequel

Best for

• Fans of mystery-driven sci-fi stories
• Players looking for tactical, ranged combat against unique enemies
• Those seeking a polished, visually stunning 'palette cleanser' game

Avoid if

• You dislike repetitive 'follow the marker' climbing and traversal
• You are looking for a deep melee-focused combat system
• You are specifically interested in the board game version, which has negative community feedback