Harrow the Ninth
Reddit take
Not enough linked mention summaries yet; the source excerpts below are the evidence.
Pros
- I agree with The Locked Tomb series. Especially Harrow the Ninth!
- Parent context: I'm still not sure I actually understand what's going on in the series despite enjoying it. I genuinely wish I had more books that felt the way Gideon the Ninth felt. Reply: However, I am also perplexed by the fact that H...
- Sorry but the knight speaking in iambic pentameter at the end negates all your points. Incredible book.
- Harrow the Ninth! You will have to read Gideon tbr Ninth first, which also has this but to a lease degree.
Cons
- I love the books; but I came very close to just setting down Harrow the Ninth and not picking it back up. So I get where you’re coming from
- I'm very disappointed I didn't like Harrow as much. But I'm a plot reader and this was a very vibes heavy book, which just isn't my thing at all.
- This book is set in a vacuum. While Gideon had a very distinct sense of place, Harrow lacks it completely. I think they're in some kind of space station because they mentioned it once. What does it look like? I have no idea because there...
- As we all know, this book has a quite convoluted plot. I get that the reason is that Harrow doesn't have her memories, but it goes on for 80 % of the book, and I think 30 % would have been more than enough.
- It also feels like it's confusing just to be confusing and tries to mislead the reader. Like I mentioned before with Gideon's voice. The same thing happens with the chapter titles "10 months until the emperor's murder". It makes you wait...
Sentiment
4 positive (29%) · 1 mixed (7%) · 9 negative (64%)
Trust + time weighted score: -34% · raw score -36%
What redditors said (10 of 14)
I love the books; but I came very close to just setting down Harrow the Ninth and not picking it back up. So I get where you’re coming from
I agree with The Locked Tomb series. Especially Harrow the Ninth!
I'm very disappointed I didn't like Harrow as much. But I'm a plot reader and this was a very vibes heavy book, which just isn't my thing at all.
Parent context: I'm still not sure I actually understand what's going on in the series despite enjoying it. I genuinely wish I had more books that felt the way Gideon the Ninth felt. Reply: However, I am also perplexed by the fact that Harrow and Nona absolutely failed in that regard, and I still enjoyed them.
Sorry but the knight speaking in iambic pentameter at the end negates all your points. Incredible book.
This book is set in a vacuum. While Gideon had a very distinct sense of place, Harrow lacks it completely. I think they're in some kind of space station because they mentioned it once. What does it look like? I have no idea because there are basically no descriptions of the environment in this book.
As we all know, this book has a quite convoluted plot. I get that the reason is that Harrow doesn't have her memories, but it goes on for 80 % of the book, and I think 30 % would have been more than enough.
It also feels like it's confusing just to be confusing and tries to mislead the reader. Like I mentioned before with Gideon's voice. The same thing happens with the chapter titles "10 months until the emperor's murder". It makes you wait to see how the emperor will die because you're told it will happen for the entire book. But then the emperor isn't murdered so it feels like a bait and switch.
The narration... makes it feel like a cheap trick to try to shock the reader rather than a logical choice for the narration. This is especially egregious in the audiobook, where the *actual* voice changes when Gideon shows up.
I must say, I had high hopes for this book but ended up very disappointed. So this is mainly a critique of what I did not like. It wasn't a completely awful book, but the bad far outweighs the good for me.
Compare
Harrow the Ninth vs The Lord of the RingsHarrow the Ninth vs PiranesiHarrow the Ninth vs Jonathan Strange and Mr Norrell
Related
- Dungeon Crawler Carl · related · 434 mentions
- Project Hail Mary · related · 325 mentions
- Between Two Fires · related · 239 mentions
- The Wheel of Time · related · 222 mentions
- Piranesi · related · 210 mentions
- House of Leaves · related · 204 mentions