Gideon the Ninth

Pros

• Unique and memorable protagonist with a singular, hilarious narrative voice.
• Intricate world-building involving necromancy, space travel, and "thanergy."
• Successful blend of multiple genres, including sci-fi, fantasy, and 'And Then There Were None'-style mystery.
• Strong representation of diverse female characters and complex antagonists.
• Highly rewarding for attentive readers who enjoy piecing together an intricate plot.

Cons

• Polarizing humor that some describe as "insufferable teenage snark" or too rooted in internet subculture.
• Initial plot and world-building can be confusing and may require a second read to fully grasp.
• Narrative voice can feel like Young Adult (YA) fiction to some readers, which may not suit all tastes.
• Unreliable narrator requires reading between the lines, which can be frustrating for those seeking a straightforward story.

Caveats

• Described as a "cilantro book": readers typically either love it or find it tastes like soap.
• The protagonist's voice and humor often take time to grow on the reader.
• The story features graphic elements described as "gross" or focused on malnutrition and death due to the necromantic setting.

Best for

• Fans of genre-blending fiction and complex mysteries.
• Readers who enjoy snarky, humorous, and unconventional protagonists.
• Those looking for queer representation in a sci-fi/fantasy setting.

Avoid if

• You dislike internet-slang-influenced humor or "Homestuck-esque" snark.
• You prefer linear, easy-to-follow narratives without unreliable narrators.
• You are looking for a traditional, serious space opera without modern comedic sensibilities.