Filson
Reddit take
AI summary of the Reddit excerpts below — not a quote
Filson is a heritage brand best known for its rugged outdoor gear, specifically its Mackinaw wool and 'tin cloth' waxed canvas. While it maintains a strong reputation for durability in its classic and Made in USA (MiUSA) lines, recent sentiment is heavily divided. Many users report a perceived decline in quality for newer production runs alongside significantly inflated prices, leading to a consensus that the brand's current value proposition is 'hit or miss' compared to its legendary vintage status.
Pros
- Exceptional durability of Mackinaw wool and 'tin cloth' waxed canvas for heavy-duty work and camping
- Vintage and 'old stock' items are highly prized for genuine 'Buy It For Life' (BIFL) longevity
- MiUSA (Made in USA) products are generally still considered to be of solid construction
- Specific items like thick flannels and wool cruisers receive high marks for quality and comfort
- Materials are noted by some to be surprisingly soft and suitable for sensitive skin
Cons
- Recent price increases are frequently described as 'ridiculous' or 'inflated'
- Perceived drop in quality for newer items compared to the brand's historical standards
- Fit can be overly 'boxy' and may not suit all body types
- Some items now feature synthetic blends (polyester) where users expected natural fibers
- Criticism regarding the outsourcing of some production to China while maintaining premium price points
Caveats
- Users frequently suggest catching items on a significant sale to justify the current cost
- There is a sharp distinction made between 'old stock' and 'new stuff,' with the latter being less trusted
- Competitors like Dehen are sometimes cited as offering a more premium build or better fit
Best for
- Outdoor professionals and enthusiasts (forestry, camping)
- Fans of heritage workwear aesthetics
- Those seeking heavy-duty wool outerwear
Avoid if
- You are looking for a slim or modern tailored fit
- You are on a strict budget and cannot find a significant sale
- You prioritize 100% natural fibers in all garment types
This summary uses balanced time weighting with about a 18-month half-life. The evidence is drawn from a mix of subreddits with a median age of 294 days, reflecting a brand with a stable legacy but currently shifting reputation.
Sentiment
16 positive (55%) · 6 mixed (21%) · 7 negative (24%)
Trust + time weighted score: +31% · raw score 31%
What redditors said (10 of 29)
The Filson zips into an oilcloth shell for rain
Went back to my filson.
Filson’s prices are kind of ridiculous these days. You have to catch them on a big sale for it to make any sense.
For canvas duck, Filson is my go to.
The new stuff is hit or miss, I did just get a thick flannel from them and it appears to be very high quality.
I have a Filson shirt that I bought in 1998, before my fieldwork began. It’s still with me and holding up great. Some of my other older filson items are holding up just as well.
Not a fan of their new stuff at all tbh
Old stock is fantastic. New stuff? Ehhhh.
Their mackinaw wool and tin cloth have held up to years of abuse from forestry work to camping and still look and function great.
About $500-$700 typically for a heavy weight, produced in the first world. Jophnson woolen mills, Filson
Compare
Filson vs Spier & MackayFilson vs SunspelFilson vs Charles Tyrwhitt