Earthlings

Pros

• Extremely memorable; readers note it sticks with them for a long time.
• Unique 'weird' tone that balances intensity with moments of humor.
• Compelling enough to be 'binge-read' by many despite its heavy content.
• Effectively handles tragic themes of abuse and psychological struggle.

Cons

• Highly polarizing; described as a 'love-it-or-hate-it' experience.
• The ending is known to go 'off the rails' into extreme 'disturbia.'
• Can be excessively bleak and gruesome for some readers.

Caveats

• Contains significant shock value and horrific elements; checking trigger warnings is strongly advised.
• Not originally marketed as horror, which may mislead readers expecting a traditional genre experience.
• Some readers found the 'shocking' nature of the book didn't align with their specific reading preferences.

Best for

• Fans of 'weird fiction' and psychological horror.
• Readers looking for books that are genuinely shocking or 'out there.'
• Those who enjoy tragic tales dealing with complex psychological issues.

Avoid if

• You are sensitive to graphic depictions of abuse or trauma.
• You prefer grounded, conventional narratives over surreal or 'batshit' plots.
• You want a light or traditionally 'scary' horror novel.