Dark Souls 2

Pros

• Exceptional atmosphere and melancholy vibe, particularly in the hub area of Majula
• Extensive build variety, including the 'powerstance' mechanic for dual-wielding different weapon types
• Strong standalone story and lore that effectively explores the series' core themes
• Improved game balance and satisfying combat animations, such as backstabs
• Large scope with many handcrafted areas and a 'less is more' approach to exploration

Cons

• Animations can feel stiff, sluggish, and lack the 'weight' found in other titles
• Downgraded sound design, specifically 'squishy' attack sounds and uninspired boss music
• Frustrating level design in specific areas, with the Iron Keep being a frequent point of criticism
• Poor keyboard and mouse controls that can be a barrier to entry
• Controversial mechanics like the 'adaptability' stat and a more linear world progression

Caveats

• The game's reputation is significantly more divisive than Dark Souls 1 or 3
• Some players find the combat 'clunky' in a way that is satisfying, while others find it a dealbreaker
• Opinions are split on whether it is better to play the trilogy in order or start with this entry for lore purposes

Best for

• Players who enjoy deep character build experimentation
• Fans of atmospheric, melancholy world-building
• Those looking for a massive RPG with a slower, more methodical combat pace

Avoid if

• You prefer the faster, more fluid movement and animations of later FromSoftware titles
• You are sensitive to 'unfair' enemy placement or frustrating level design
• You intend to play primarily with keyboard and mouse controls