Codex Alera
Reddit take
Not enough linked mention summaries yet; the source excerpts below are the evidence.
Pros
- Its just a great story.
- Codex Alera after book 2 is fantastic and the romance is so well written. I wish this series got more love.
- I would say the strong point of the Codex Alera is following a competent character. It's quite satisfying watching Tavi grow, and while he make some bad decisions due to immaturity, he's satisfyingly written as a *smart* MC.
- Codex Alera is a good choice but takes a bit to form said power couples (a couple books). Still a good fit though.
- The first book is pretty good, and the rest are great. Fun world and cast. And best of all, it's not too long or too short - 6 good-sized books - and it's *finished*.
Cons
- Parent context: Hehe, sorry. Tobias. Brain glitch. But Tobias Begley is the one I like. I haven’t read Travis Riddle’s work yet, but I am intrigued by a pokemon-like that isn’t Codex Alera, which felt a little very misogynistic (even wit...
- In 2009 Jim Butcher, author of The Dresden Files and the Codex Alera series, was asked to write a "reboot" of the original trilogy.
- Codex alera base premise was the the whole "you can't write a story about that".
- The Pokemon + Roman legion thing is accurate for the very beginning of the series but it quickly abandons the Pokemon flavor in favour of just making it elemental magic and downplaying any role the furies have in it.
- Instead, I'd describe it as Game of Thrones lite with Avatar the Last Airbender magic system. The main plot of the story revolves around political intrigue of multiple different houses scheming and betraying each other to become the next...
Sentiment
5 positive (45%) · 5 mixed (45%) · 1 negative (9%)
Trust + time weighted score: +42% · raw score 36%
What redditors said (10 of 11)
Its just a great story.
Codex Alera after book 2 is fantastic and the romance is so well written. I wish this series got more love.
I would say the strong point of the Codex Alera is following a competent character. It's quite satisfying watching Tavi grow, and while he make some bad decisions due to immaturity, he's satisfyingly written as a *smart* MC.
Parent context: Hehe, sorry. Tobias. Brain glitch. But Tobias Begley is the one I like. I haven’t read Travis Riddle’s work yet, but I am intrigued by a pokemon-like that isn’t Codex Alera, which felt a little very misogynistic (even with an empowered female main character). Reply: Hehe, sorry. Tobias. Brain glitch. But Tobias Begley is the one I like. I haven’t read Travis Riddle’s work yet, but I am intrigued by a pokemon-like that isn’t Codex Alera, which felt a little very misogynistic (even with an empowered female main character).
In 2009 Jim Butcher, author of The Dresden Files and the Codex Alera series, was asked to write a "reboot" of the original trilogy.
Codex alera base premise was the the whole "you can't write a story about that".
Codex Alera is a good choice but takes a bit to form said power couples (a couple books). Still a good fit though.
The Pokemon + Roman legion thing is accurate for the very beginning of the series but it quickly abandons the Pokemon flavor in favour of just making it elemental magic and downplaying any role the furies have in it.
Instead, I'd describe it as Game of Thrones lite with Avatar the Last Airbender magic system. The main plot of the story revolves around political intrigue of multiple different houses scheming and betraying each other to become the next ruler of the nation.
The only thing pokemon about the story is that the elemental powers manifest as a unique creature owned by each person. And that even feels more like Golden Compass Daemons than Pokemon.
Compare
Codex Alera vs DiscworldCodex Alera vs MurderbotCodex Alera vs The Expanse
Related
- Dungeon Crawler Carl · related · 434 mentions
- Project Hail Mary · related · 325 mentions
- Between Two Fires · related · 239 mentions
- The Wheel of Time · related · 222 mentions
- Piranesi · related · 210 mentions
- House of Leaves · related · 204 mentions