BioShock

Pros

• I'd say the first two Bioshock games are worth playing. The first has a good story and is very atmospheric.
• It felt a little artsy, very "meta" in a way that I hadn't seen in a game before then (actually, I guess Bioshock kind of hit on the idea of limited player agency, at least implicitly).
• Really, no mention of the love letter to Art Deco that is Bioshock's Rapture?
• I'm no stranger to scrounging for supplies in games. I like Bioshock, Prey, and Metro.
• Bioshock beats this hands down.

Cons

• I somehow have a higher tolerance for System Shock than newer games like BioShock
• One weirdly distracting thing about Bioshock was that your character appears to be about three feet tall. Whenever you come to a door, you’ll notice that the handle is approximately at eye level.
• Obviously, there's some positions that are hard to reflect in a game. (I think BioShock had something to say about that.)
• The first and second I tried but got bored with.
• Worst hacking easily goes to Bioshock. it was widely panned as a black mark on this otherwise praised game, and for good reason. It really distracts, its not fun, and you HAVE to do it as the rewards are too massive.