Apple Pencil
Reddit take
AI summary of the Reddit excerpts below — not a quote
The Apple Pencil is widely praised for its precision in drawing and its utility for students, though it faces consistent comparisons to the Samsung S-Pen regarding writing feel. While users appreciate its ergonomic design and the way iPad apps are optimized for it, many find the hard tip to be loud and slippery on glass without additional accessories.
Pros
- Excellent performance for drawing and artistic applications
- Deep integration with iPadOS and optimized third-party apps
- Ergonomic design that many users find fits the hand better than competitors
- Highly reliable and easy to purchase compared to niche brand styluses
Cons
- Hard tip creates an audible clicking sound and lacks friction on glass
- Noticeable lag in certain apps that do not utilize native Apple APIs
- Typically sold as a separate, premium-priced accessory
- Third-party alternatives often lack pressure sensitivity, supporting only tilt
Caveats
- Users often feel the need to buy 'paper-like' screen protectors or specialized tips to replicate a natural writing feel
- The user experience is highly dependent on whether the specific app used is optimized for Apple's stylus APIs
Best for
- Digital artists and illustrators
- Students who want to centralize notes, planners, and presentations
- Users seeking a stable and well-supported stylus within the Apple ecosystem
Avoid if
- You prefer the softer, quieter writing feel of a rubberized nib like the S-Pen
- You are on a strict budget and require full pressure sensitivity
This summary uses balanced time weighting with about a 6-month half-life. The evidence is older, with a median source age of approximately 387 days, which may not reflect the most recent hardware revisions or software improvements.
Sentiment
13 positive (57%) · 2 mixed (9%) · 8 negative (35%)
Trust + time weighted score: +17% · raw score 22%
What redditors said (10 of 23)
The Apple Pencil is absolutely great for drawing. Fantastic even.
I have an old iPad 7 and found the Apple Pencil experience amazing.
On the other hand Apple uses a hard one.
HOWEVER to Apple Pencil, thirdparty Pencils won't support pressure se'itivity, only tilt.
Apple Pencil on an iPad screen is audible and louder than the Samsungs.
You check if there's any Apple Store at your place and try the iPad + Apple Pencil hand on.
Apple Pencil has remarkable lag with apps that don't use Apple APIs (like Goodnotes).
In the past I have actually preferred the S-Pen to the Apple Pencil. Though more recently I purchased tips for the Apple Pencil that replicate the feel of an actual pencil (similar to the S-Pen).
The Pencil feels super natural
However, i liked apple pencil more but samsung is free and not that bad.
Compare
Apple Pencil vs S PenApple Pencil vs Apple Pencil proApple Pencil vs Dynamic Island
Related
- Apple Pencil pro · variant · 13 mentions
- iPhone · related · 970 mentions
- Amazon Kindle · related · 527 mentions
- Kobo · related · 443 mentions
- iPhone 17 · related · 437 mentions
- iPad · related · 430 mentions
- Kobo Libra Colour · related · 279 mentions