Side by side
Vanicream Cleanser vs La Roche-Posay Cleanser
Vanicream Cleanser
109 positive (80%) · 9 mixed (7%) · 18 negative (13%)
Trust + time weighted: +68%
AI summary — not a quote
Vanicream Cleanser is widely regarded as a reliable, "back-to-basics" staple for sensitive and reactive skin. It is frequently recommended by users for its gentle, non-stripping formula that cleanses without the use of harsh actives, making it a go-to choice for those with rosacea or a compromised skin barrier.
Pros
- Extremely gentle and non-stripping on the skin
- Highly effective for sensitive and rosacea-prone skin
- Ideal for use while on retinoids or healing a damaged skin barrier
- Reliable performance in harsh winter climates
Cons
- May cause clogged pores for some users with oily or combination skin
- Less effective at removing heavy makeup compared to some competitors
- Occasional reports of stinging or irritation on highly reactive skin
Top excerpts
Switch to something gentle and non-active. Vanicream Gentle Cleanser or something similar with no actives at all. Just clean your skin without stripping it.
PM: 1) wash face w vanicream gentle facial cleanser, PAT skin dry.
Vanicream gentle facial cleanser for example.
Vanicream face wash and moisturizer until your barrier is healed, no actives!
I used to use the Cerave hydrating cleanser that said it can remove makeup on the bottle. I liked it over the Vanicream because it felt like did a better job cleansing for me.
La Roche-Posay Cleanser
30 positive (70%) · 12 mixed (28%) · 1 negative (2%)
Trust + time weighted: +74%
AI summary — not a quote
La Roche-Posay's hydrating gentle cleanser is widely regarded on Reddit as a staple for sensitive and reactive skin. It is frequently recommended as a mild, non-stripping alternative to harsher cleansers, often favored by users who find other popular brands like CeraVe to be irritating. The product is typically used as a foundational piece in simple skincare routines, especially for those managing skin barrier repair or using strong actives like tretinoin.
Pros
- Extremely gentle and mild on reactive or damaged skin
- Hydrating formula that does not leave the skin feeling stripped
- Effective as a second step in a double-cleansing routine
- Highly compatible with other basic skincare brands like Vanicream
Cons
- May not be sufficient on its own to remove heavy makeup or waterproof sunscreen without a pre-cleanse step
Top excerpts
I’ve since switched to La Roche Posay Hydrating Gentle Cleanser and stopped using the oil control pads.
But otherwise I would probably go with Cerave again or La Roche Posay has a hydrating gentle cleanser I like.
I only use La Roche posay gentle hydrating cleanser and vanicream moisturizer so I try to keep it simple.
I currently use la roche-posay hydrating gentle cleanser, prequel aha exfoliate, vanicream moisturizer
Switch to la Roche posay cleanser and moisturizer?