Side by side
Toyota Avalon vs Mazda 6
Toyota Avalon
71 positive (90%) · 4 mixed (5%) · 4 negative (5%)
Trust + time weighted: +88%
AI summary — not a quote
The Toyota Avalon is highly regarded as a reliable, comfortable, and near-luxury sedan that serves as a premium alternative to the Camry or a more affordable substitute for the Lexus ES. Reddit users frequently praise its smooth V6 engine, spacious interior, and long-term durability, with many considering it an ideal vehicle for long-distance road trips. Although the model has been discontinued, it remains a top recommendation in the used car market for buyers seeking a 'substantial' and 'heavy' road feel combined with Toyota's signature longevity.
Pros
- Exceptional long-term reliability, with users noting potential lifespans of 250,000 to 300,000 miles.
- High level of interior comfort, specifically regarding seat quality and cabin space.
- Smooth and powerful V6 engine performance that provides a 'substantial' feel on the road.
- Excellent value proposition, offering luxury features like leather interiors and sunroofs at a lower price point than dedicated luxury brands.
Cons
- The model is discontinued, which may make specific configurations harder to find.
- Mixed reports on fuel economy, with some users noting older models can be thirsty for fuel.
- Potentially higher running costs compared to smaller economy cars like the Corolla or Civic.
Top excerpts
Older Civic / Accord / Camry / Avalon off Craigslist probs your best bet.
Toyota Avalon sedan would be my first choice.
Toyota Avalon at 175k for $6,100 is the budget-smart choice. Avalons regularly go to 250k+ with basic maintenance. ... With records it's probably 70-80k miles of life left at minimum.
12k luxury? Maybe an old Toyota Avalon
Toyota Avalon, 2005-2012. ... I have them both. Can readily get them for under 5k if you are ok with the basic le sienna.
Mazda 6
136 positive (81%) · 20 mixed (12%) · 11 negative (7%)
Trust + time weighted: +75%
AI summary — not a quote
The Mazda 6 is widely regarded by owners and enthusiasts as a refined, reliable, and 'sporty' alternative to mainstream midsize sedans like the Honda Accord and Toyota Camry. It is frequently praised for its superior handling, build quality, and premium interior feel, though it is often noted as having 'outdated' technology compared to newer competitors. Despite being discontinued in several markets, it remains a highly recommended choice for those who prioritize driving dynamics and aesthetic appeal over the latest infotainment features.
Pros
- Excellent handling and 'zippy' driving dynamics for a midsize sedan
- High-quality interior refinement and build quality, especially in higher trims
- Strong long-term reliability with regular maintenance
- Timeless and attractive exterior styling
Cons
- Infotainment and cabin technology feel outdated compared to newer rivals
- Base variants may lack modern features like adaptive cruise control or leather seats
- Maintenance costs can be slightly higher than some Japanese competitors
- Lack of an AWD turbo option which some enthusiasts desire
Top excerpts
I really like Mazda. I used to have a 6 and it was great. I think it might be underrated here.
My limited experience with an older 6 was definitely positive.
Mazda 6 is also something solid to look at.
Depending on the safety tech features you want a new Mazda 6 would be a good choice. The top trim was around 104k a few months ago. Maybe it’s cheaper now. It’s a got a robust 2.5 litre engine which as enough power and it’s easily the best looking sedan out there.
Honda Accord , Mazda 6 better than Mazda 3