Side by side
Silicone Scar Tape vs Vaseline
Silicone Scar Tape
9 positive (90%) · 1 mixed (10%) · 0 negative (0%)
Trust + time weighted: +93%
AI summary — not a quote
Silicone scar tape is highly recommended by users as a medically proven, non-invasive method for minimizing the appearance of scars and speeding up the healing process. While it is noted for its effectiveness on both new and old scars, users emphasize that it requires consistent use over several months and will not completely erase a scar to 100%.
Pros
- Medically proven non-procedural method for scar minimization
- Effective on older scars as well as new ones
- Can be used off-label to prevent sleep lines caused by side-sleeping
- Generally gentle adhesive that is often reusable
Cons
- Will not achieve 100% scar removal
- Requires long-term, 'religious' application (often 6-12 months) for best results
Top excerpts
Silicone scar bandages are effective, even for old scars, but will never get you to 100%.
silicone scar tape is only medically proven way to minimize appearance of these scars without procedures
Silicone scar tape once it's healed, hydrocolloid patch until then!
sounds smart actuallly
I ordered silicone scar tape that has done WONDERS. I think it will be a good option for you to use as soon as your wound heals.
Vaseline
193 positive (77%) · 26 mixed (10%) · 31 negative (12%)
Trust + time weighted: +67%
AI summary — not a quote
Vaseline (petroleum jelly) is widely regarded as a "god-tier" occlusive, primarily used in skincare to seal in moisture and protect the skin barrier. It is the standard product for "slugging"—applying a thin layer over moisturizer at night—to prevent transepidermal water loss. While it does not hydrate the skin on its own, it is highly effective for healing dry patches, protecting minor wounds, and soothing conditions like eczema. Beyond skincare, it is also noted for its utility in camping as a fire-starting aid when paired with cotton.
Pros
- Excellent occlusive that effectively locks in moisture and treatments
- Supports skin barrier repair and reduces transepidermal water loss
- Versatile application for lips, feet, dry patches, and eczema
- Promotes moist wound healing and protects raw or irritated skin
Cons
- Does not provide hydration or active skin treatment on its own
- Heavy, greasy texture can be uncomfortable for some users
- May clog pores or cause breakouts for specific skin types
- Can trap heat, which may exacerbate certain inflammatory skin responses
Top excerpts
Vaseline is now considered the standard for helping broken skin heal. Whenever I get cracks in my hands I get them moist and put a daub of Vaseline in/on the crack. At night I put a good amount and wrap with a bandaid.
check out 'slugging' at night, which is just using an occlusive layer (Vaseline) to seal in moisture. Helps some, but not everyone!
Moisturizer after Tret sits on your skin for 10 minutes, and then add a thin layer of Vaseline.
Sometimes, I like to go overkill mode on the nuclear option and seal the Cosrx with vaseline at night. I don't think it does much more, but I have spare vaseline in my cabinet, so I'll do it anyways.
Don’t use any actives on it and keep it moist - a layer of Vaseline or Aquaphor will help.