Side by side
Old Forester 1924 vs Eagle Rare
Old Forester 1924
78 positive (84%) · 14 mixed (15%) · 1 negative (1%)
Trust + time weighted: +83%
AI summary — not a quote
Old Forester 1924 is a 10-year-old addition to the Whiskey Row series that is highly regarded for its flavor profile but frequently criticized for its premium price point. Enthusiasts often describe it as a "Baby Birthday Bourbon," offering a complex, chocolate and dark cherry-forward experience at 100 proof. While the liquid quality is consistently praised, a significant portion of the community finds it difficult to justify the ~$100+ MSRP when other well-regarded Whiskey Row bottles like 1910 and 1920 are available for nearly half the price.
Pros
- Complex flavor profile featuring notes of chocolate, dark cherry, leather, and polished oak.
- Often compared favorably to the highly elusive Birthday Bourbon in terms of character.
- Excellent sipping experience for a 100-proof whiskey, showing significant aged character.
- Generally preferred by enthusiasts over other 10-year competitors like Jack Daniel's 10-Year.
Cons
- High MSRP (often $100-$115) is a major deterrent for value-conscious buyers.
- The 100 proof may feel underpowered for drinkers who prefer barrel-strength or high-proof expressions.
- Some users noted the body can feel slightly thin despite the complex flavors.
Top excerpts
5.7 | Good | Good, just fine Old Forester 1924 (5.7)
1924 is on its own level - all love, solid 7.5 from me. $99 from Costco - it was a must try based on the reviews here. It didn't disappoint as I veer towards to the sweet end of bourbons in general.
This bottle rocks. I do wish it was either cask strength OR high proof (similar to 1920). Feel like it would be stellar without being watered down; mouthfeel, finish, some more oak.
Catching 1924 at Costco for $100 is a steal, that price makes it a no-brainer over 1920 in my book.
I was overwhelmed by the red fruits you mention on the palate. I thought it was a flavorful, easy sipper. I tend to like higher proof bourbons but this seems to drink a bit higher than its proof. I love it. The nose is incredible and the flavor matches the nose for me.
Eagle Rare
63 positive (83%) · 9 mixed (12%) · 4 negative (5%)
Trust + time weighted: +81%
AI summary — not a quote
Eagle Rare is widely considered one of the best value bourbons on the market, praised for its smooth, complex profile that balances caramel, cherry, and honey notes. However, its reputation is frequently overshadowed by extreme availability issues, with many enthusiasts noting it is rarely found on shelves at its intended MSRP.
Pros
- Exceptional value when purchased at MSRP (typically $30-$40).
- Smooth and approachable flavor profile with notes of caramel, cherry, and grape.
- Greater complexity and sophistication compared to standard Buffalo Trace offerings.
- Highly regarded as a 'staple' bottle for neat sipping.
Cons
- Extremely difficult to find due to being an 'allocated' product.
- Frequently subject to significant price markups or secondary market gouging.
- Some enthusiasts find it overhyped, rating it as 'average' compared to more available high-proof alternatives.
Top excerpts
Fun place to visit and the best prices of Eagle Rare you’ll find.
Eagle Rare is the standard at MSRP. I rather have two bottles vs a single Blantons.
ER is the perfect bourbon if you're just trying to chill and drink something light but still flavorful.
I looooove ER
RR10 is one of my faves, and I don’t particularly like Eagle Rare.