Side by side
Gone Girl vs The Outsider
Gone Girl
37 positive (97%) · 1 mixed (3%) · 0 negative (0%)
Trust + time weighted: +97%
Top excerpts
Also Gone Girl.
I read “Gone Girl” with no information (found it at a cabin on vacation)
5. Gone Girl by Gillian Flynn
It’s not a bad book, I don’t mind the writing style and I was looking forward to the plot. I started getting into reading the past couple of years and one thing I wanted to challenge myself was reading more mystery, thriller types of books but this one is very triggering
Gone girl maybe? Depends how you define unhinged I guess.
The Outsider
19 positive (79%) · 5 mixed (21%) · 0 negative (0%)
Trust + time weighted: +81%
AI summary — not a quote
The Outsider is highly regarded by readers as a compelling hybrid of a grounded murder mystery and supernatural horror. While the first half is almost universally praised for its intense tension and procedural mystery, the second half's shift into paranormal territory and the eventual resolution are points of mild contention among fans.
Pros
- Masterful tension and mystery in the first half of the book.
- Highly recommended audiobook version.
- Engaging, short chapters that maintain a fast pace despite the book's length.
- Strong character work, particularly the inclusion of Holly Gibney.
Cons
- The final confrontation and reveal are frequently described as underwhelming or 'sputtering' compared to the buildup.
- The transition from a grounded mystery to a supernatural one may be jarring for some readers.
- Typical of the author's style, some find the overall length slightly excessive.
Top excerpts
Completely agree, the mystery was way more interesting than the reveal.
The Outsider by Stephen King would be perfect!
I would like to add to this that the audiobook for The Outsider, Only Good Indians, and The Buffalo Hunter Hunter are so good.
The Outsider- Stephen King
Some of my other favorites by him are Pickman's Model, The Outsider, The Statement of Randolph carter.