Side by side

Gone Girl vs Pretty Girls

Gone Girl (38 mentions) vs Pretty Girls (10 mentions): verbatim Reddit excerpts, sentiment split and trust-weighted score side by side.

Gone Girl

Thriller, mystery & crime books · 38 mentions · 4 subreddits · #1 of 12 in Thriller, mystery & crime books

37 positive (97%) · 1 mixed (3%) · 0 negative (0%)

Trust + time weighted: +97%

Top excerpts

Also Gone Girl.

positive · u/E****6 · r/suggestmeabook · comment · Aug 26, 2026 · open on Reddit ↗

I read “Gone Girl” with no information (found it at a cabin on vacation)

positive · u/u****m · r/suggestmeabook · Aug 25, 2026 · open on Reddit ↗

5. Gone Girl by Gillian Flynn

positive · u/c****1 · r/suggestmeabook · comment · Jul 22, 2026 · open on Reddit ↗

It’s not a bad book, I don’t mind the writing style and I was looking forward to the plot. I started getting into reading the past couple of years and one thing I wanted to challenge myself was reading more mystery, thriller types of books but this one is very triggering

mixed · u/G****0 · r/BookRecommendations · Jul 10, 2026 · open on Reddit ↗

Gone girl maybe? Depends how you define unhinged I guess.

positive · u/A****3 · r/suggestmeabook · comment · Jul 8, 2026 · open on Reddit ↗

Pretty Girls

Thriller, mystery & crime books · 10 mentions · 2 subreddits · #5 of 12 in Thriller, mystery & crime books

9 positive (90%) · 0 mixed (0%) · 1 negative (10%)

Trust + time weighted: +80%

Top excerpts

Pretty Girls by Karen Slaughter (actually a very dark crime thriller)

positive · u/M****5 · r/horrorlit · comment · Nov 11, 2025 · open on Reddit ↗

Karin Slaughter's Pretty Girls or The Good Daughter.

positive · u/P****p · r/BookRecommendations · comment · Nov 21, 2025 · open on Reddit ↗

I loved it, but I enjoyed it from start to finish. There’s no big redemption arc at the end if you hate the characters.

positive · u/s****n · r/horrorlit · comment · Jul 13, 2025 · open on Reddit ↗

I also really liked it. I thought it was very suspenseful and entertaining.

positive · u/6****d · r/horrorlit · comment · Jul 13, 2025 · open on Reddit ↗

I enjoyed it. It definitely wasn’t the best thing Ive ever read but it was entertaining.

positive · u/n****8 · r/horrorlit · comment · Jul 13, 2025 · open on Reddit ↗