BMW M240i vs Porsche Cayman

If you want to spend $50k on a rwd car, obvious choices include the Nissan Z, BMW M240i, a Miata and a year's rent

if you want a B58 in a sports car / get BMW M240i. Much more spacious than Supra

the m240i reigns supreme since it’s sporty ish and also a great daily.

M240i fits your budget and gets you 382hp with a way nicer interior than the GR86, plus the tech is solid.

Brand new? A Supra GR Premium or a BMW m240i.

I do need a backseat otherwise the Cayman would be ideal.

Get the Cayman. If you get a good one with ppi you will be driving a special car.

They cayman is a special vehicle, they’re comfortable to daily unless you’re going into like a hardcore one, and have a surprising amount of storage space with a trunk and frunk. I’d go there, because they also don’t depreciate like the VW, and it’s just going to be a better version of the GR86

Cayman would treat you right. Just make sure to get a ppi and check for bore score

A Cayman or Boxster, or an M2 would be my choices.