Tricker's
Reddit take
AI summary of the Reddit excerpts below — not a quote
Tricker's is a highly respected, family-run British shoemaker known for its robust "country" aesthetic and substantial construction. While retail prices are considered high, the brand is frequently cited as one of the best values in high-end footwear when purchased during their biannual sales or through their outlet store.
Pros
- Excellent value when purchased at sale prices (often 40-70% off)
- High-quality Goodyear welted construction with wood shanks
- Known for offering wide-fitting options that remain comfortable for all-day wear
- Respected as a traditional, family-run company that avoids venture capital influence
- Durable and substantial feel compared to other heritage brands
Cons
- High MSRP makes them less competitive at full retail price
- Aesthetic is often too chunky or "country" for formal city suits
- Large broguing holes are a polarizing design choice for some users
- Leather can be stiff and requires a break-in period or regular maintenance
Caveats
- Dainite soles on some models have been described as exceptionally hard
- Specific leather makeups (like Kudu) may feature natural scarring that is typical for the material
- Occasional reports of inconsistent stitch density on newer models
Best for
- Casual or rugged heritage outfits
- Buyers who can wait for seasonal sales or shop the outlet
- Individuals requiring wider shoe profiles
Avoid if
- You need a sleek, slim-profile dress shoe for formal business wear
- You prefer a lightweight or flexible sole immediately out of the box
This summary uses balanced time weighting with about a 18-month half-life. The evidence is drawn from a consistent history of discussions in specialized footwear communities, with a median source age of approximately 389 days.
Sentiment
22 positive (59%) · 12 mixed (32%) · 3 negative (8%)
Trust + time weighted score: +51% · raw score 51%
What redditors said (10 of 37)
I’ve had Tricker’s and OSB trench boots resoled by Unsung and everything about the experience was fantastic each time. The customer service was amazing, the appointment process made it quite quick, and the work was top notch.
I have a pair of pretty new Trickers with noticeably lower stitch density on the sole stitching.
Trickers is somewhat higher volume, but what makes them look more hefty is the bigger holes of the broguing, which have never found grace to my eyes.
Tricker’s and Grenson boots are probably too chunky/country for a city suit.
saw a neat Japanese brand called Manufacturers Standard whose shoes felt as substantial as Tricker’s when I picked them up.
Only experience is with Tricker’s. They bake it into the cost. Delivery was less a week.
Look at Tricker's, Crockett & Jones, Grant Stone, or Alden.
Parent context: I see the controls now. Pic 4 is the real issue. 3 is just a welt joint. 2 will buff out. As will 6. But pic 6 also shows a bad storm welt (poorly done.) Return. Look at Trickers in this price range. Reply: Look on herring and afinepairofshoes as they have some on sale and with unusual leather makeups.
In some great shoes I have -Alden, trickers, viberg, Etc- inside they have that glued in heel pad only up to like the middle of the arch.
If you want something more in-between in profile, check out Tricker's.
Compare
Tricker's vs Nicks BootsTricker's vs Beckett SimononTricker's vs Grant Stone
Related
- Alden · related · 86 mentions
- Allen Edmonds · related · 83 mentions
- Blundstone · related · 77 mentions
- Meermin · related · 77 mentions
- Grant Stone · related · 73 mentions
- Viberg · related · 59 mentions