Toyota Highlander
Reddit take
AI summary of the Reddit excerpts below — not a quote
The Toyota Highlander is widely recognized on Reddit as a benchmark for long-term reliability and low cost of ownership in the mid-size SUV segment. While it is frequently praised for its ability to reach high mileage (250k-500k miles) and its strong resale value, it is often described as a 'boring' or uninspiring vehicle to drive. Opinions are mixed regarding its utility, with many users noting that the third row and cargo space are cramped compared to competitors.
Pros
- Exceptional long-term reliability and mechanical longevity.
- Lower maintenance and ownership costs compared to European luxury brands.
- Strong resale value, even for high-mileage units.
- Quiet cabin and comfortable front-row seating.
- Hybrid variants offer class-leading fuel efficiency.
Cons
- Cramped third-row seating and limited cargo space behind the rear seats.
- Uninspiring or 'boring' driving dynamics.
- Infotainment systems in older generations are frequently criticized as dated or poor.
- High entry price on the used market due to brand reputation.
Caveats
- Recent models (including the Grand Highlander) have been noted by users as potential targets for theft.
- Mechanically very similar to the Lexus RX, which may offer a more premium experience for a similar used price.
- The vehicle may be too small for those requiring the space of a full-size SUV like a Tahoe or Sequoia.
Best for
- Buyers prioritizing reliability and low depreciation over driving excitement.
- Small families who only occasionally need a third row.
- Tall drivers, as users report good legroom for long inseams.
Avoid if
- You require a functional third row for adults or frequent cargo hauling.
- You are looking for an engaging or 'fun' driving experience.
- You are shopping for a budget-friendly used SUV, as Highlander prices remain high.
This summary uses balanced time weighting with about a 6-month half-life. The evidence is drawn from a significant volume of mentions (118) with a median source age of approximately 289 days, providing a stable view of the vehicle's reputation across multiple years of production.
Sentiment
80 positive (60%) · 29 mixed (22%) · 24 negative (18%)
Trust + time weighted score: +41% · raw score 42%
What redditors said (10 of 133)
Maintained at a Euro Indy these cost about 1.5x compared to say a Toyota Highlander.
I would look for a used Toyota Highlander or Honda Pilot in your situation.
I have three young kids and previously had a Highlander. Now I drive an Odyssey, and honestly, there is no comparison when it comes to practicality. Third rows in many SUVs are cramped, difficult to access, and can have limitations with car-seat anchors.
Have a 2019 Highlander (husbands vehicle) and I hate driving it and it has a laughable third row. I’m 4’11” and don’t fit back there. It’s also visually unappealing inside and everything looks kind of dingy despite it only being 7 years old.
I just got rid of mine last week; Toyota Highlander. She has well over 200k miles. I put over 150k miles on it with it having zero engine problems. Not a one. If I would have taken better care of the body, (or not lived in Michigan) I would have taken her to 300k. It was an 03. That generation is known for lasting.
You can also probe a Highlander and pay 40% over competitors just for the toyota badge... Also the Highlanders are very cheaply made, have next to no sound insulation and you should really try to bum-test those seats for at least 20-30 min. You back may have its own opinion on the car then.
Also look out for 01’-07’ Toyota highlanders, specifically the 3.3 version over the 2.4.
I would suggest an older used Toyota 4Runner (3rd-4th gen V6) or Highlander. Mileage range 100-150K miles. Plenty of room to roll out a sleeping bag after putting the rear seats down. ... the Highlander is more of an on-road AWD CUV.
Very refined and comfortable. However: It felt noticeably lower than the Pajero. Most trims are hybrid, and my dad would rather stick with a conventional petrol engine.
if you need something bigger the crv or highlander. boring but they just dont die
Compare
Toyota Highlander vs Tank 300Toyota Highlander vs Mazda CX-5Toyota Highlander vs Tank 500
Related
- Canon EOS R8 · related · 736 mentions
- Toyota Corolla · related · 523 mentions
- Toyota Camry · related · 518 mentions
- Honda Odyssey · related · 487 mentions
- Toyota Sienna · related · 480 mentions
- Mazda CX-5 · related · 406 mentions