Stolen Tongues

Pros

• Highly effective 'mimic' horror and creepy supernatural imagery
• Strong atmosphere, especially recommended for 'cabin in the woods' or 'snowed in' scenarios
• High tension and genuine scares in the first third of the book
• Focus on a protective and caring relationship between the main characters

Cons

• The plot is frequently described as becoming repetitive in the latter half
• The ending and final reveal are often cited as disappointing or nonsensical
• Audiobook narration is heavily criticized for the narrator's portrayal of female dialogue
• Pacing can feel rushed, sometimes failing to sit with the characters' fear

Caveats

• Readers are sharply divided: some overlook the plot flaws for the quality of the scares, while others find the decline in quality after the first half deal-breaking.
• One reader noted a heavy reliance on dialogue early on to establish character stakes rather than organic storytelling.

Best for

• Fans of supernatural horror involving mimics and forest settings
• Readers looking for a book that is 'actually scary' in its first half
• Fans of 'cabin in the woods' tropes

Avoid if

• You prioritize a strong, cohesive ending over initial scares
• You are sensitive to repetitive plot structures
• You primarily consume books via audiobook (due to specific narrator complaints)