Penpal
Reddit take
AI summary of the Reddit excerpts below — not a quote
Penpal is a horror novel by Dathan Auerbach that originated as a popular r/nosleep creepypasta series. It follows a man recounting a childhood experience of being terrorized by a stalker. While many readers find it deeply unsettling and effective at building suspense, it is polarizing due to its origins; critics often cite a juvenile writing style and a disappointing or confusing final act.
Pros
- Highly unsettling and unnerving atmosphere
- Fast-paced and engaging readability
- Effective use of suspense and paranoia
- Strong early chapters that hook the reader
Cons
- Writing style is frequently described as juvenile
- The third act and ending are often viewed as underwhelming or nonsensical
- Minimal improvements made in the transition from web serial to published novel
- The 'reveal' may be disappointing for those expecting a supernatural twist
Caveats
- The book is a novelized creepypasta, which significantly influences its structure and prose
- High levels of hype in horror communities can lead to a sense of letdown for some readers
Best for
- Fans of creepypasta-style horror
- Readers looking for a quick, eerie, and suspenseful story
- Those who enjoy themes of childhood trauma and grounded stalking scenarios
Avoid if
- You prefer polished or literary prose
- You require a logically satisfying or complex third-act payoff
- You are specifically looking for supernatural horror
This summary uses balanced time weighting with about a 122-month half-life. The evidence comes from 19 mentions in r/horrorlit with a median age of approximately 429 days.
Sentiment
16 positive (48%) · 8 mixed (24%) · 9 negative (27%)
Trust + time weighted score: +20% · raw score 21%
What redditors said (10 of 33)
Just finished Penpal which I really enjoyed and sped through.
read Penpal after seeing many recommendations on reddit. I feel like I would have gotten more out of reading it one or two of the r/nosleep posts instead of powering through the last half of the book.
Between it and penpal, I'm not reading any other books that started out as reddit posts
For more ideas about what I found scary: Penpal by Dathan Aurbach
The plot is riddled with holes to the point of being completely non-sensical. I read the original posts and hoped that the longer story would shore things up. It just made them worse.
It’s a nosleep story that got hyped and then the writer had to really stretch out details. Just another case of a great short story being milked for a full publish
I loved the penpal podcast episodes on nosleep, but when reading the book I’m just like… why are these children 6 and alone in the woods. Their interactions would’ve made much more sense if they were 10-12
I loved it. It's a little eerie one. ... Maybe you'd like the story more if you read it in its original short form, I prefer the long one because all the added life detail stuff.
I wish I could like it because some of the ideas were good, but I just can’t suspend my disbelief
This was legitimately one of the worst horror books I ever finished, and I definitely would have DNF'd it if not for the short ~230 page length and how often the book seems to be mentioned.
Compare
Penpal vs Dark MatterPenpal vs MiseryPenpal vs Books of Blood
Related
- Dungeon Crawler Carl · related · 434 mentions
- Project Hail Mary · related · 325 mentions
- Between Two Fires · related · 239 mentions
- Piranesi · related · 210 mentions
- House of Leaves · related · 204 mentions
- We Used to Live Here · related · 180 mentions