Hanon
Reddit take
Not enough linked mention summaries yet; the source excerpts below are the evidence.
Pros
- I bought Alfred's adult piano books and a few theory books & I think hanon.
- Do you have a technique routine included in your practice? Scales, Chords, arpeggios and even hanon?
- A lot of people here hate it, but I honestly think it’s essential for learning how to play more fluently. It is a lot of exercises designed to teach your fingers certain techniques.
- Then I'll typically do some sort of Etude study such as Czerny, Hanon, or the like.
- As to the rest things I try to do all technical exercises (scales, Hanon etc) in the morning and practice sight-reading in the evening.
Cons
- Hanon: you should burn this book. Nothing to do with the edition, Hanon just sucks. Very bad for your technique.
- Hanon contains actively bad piano pedagogy, but there is value in using the patterns of its exercises while not applying that pedagogy, I suppose.
- Each étude will be focused on a specific skill and they’re fun enough that youre still learning to play a ‘piece’ instead of doing drills like Hanon for finger dexterity.
- It’s boring but I think Hanon will act as your toolbox 🧰 if u can get through some of those exercises I think you’ll find at least the moving fingers part of piano less painful.
- Hanon vs. no Hanon
Sentiment
6 positive (35%) · 7 mixed (41%) · 4 negative (24%)
Trust + time weighted score: +6% · raw score 12%
What redditors said (10 of 17)
Hanon: you should burn this book. Nothing to do with the edition, Hanon just sucks. Very bad for your technique.
Hanon contains actively bad piano pedagogy, but there is value in using the patterns of its exercises while not applying that pedagogy, I suppose.
Each étude will be focused on a specific skill and they’re fun enough that youre still learning to play a ‘piece’ instead of doing drills like Hanon for finger dexterity.
It’s boring but I think Hanon will act as your toolbox 🧰 if u can get through some of those exercises I think you’ll find at least the moving fingers part of piano less painful.
I bought Alfred's adult piano books and a few theory books & I think hanon.
Hanon vs. no Hanon
Do you have a technique routine included in your practice? Scales, Chords, arpeggios and even hanon?
A lot of people here hate it, but I honestly think it’s essential for learning how to play more fluently. It is a lot of exercises designed to teach your fingers certain techniques.
I know Czerny is often recommended (especially over Hanon)
Then I'll typically do some sort of Etude study such as Czerny, Hanon, or the like.