trustmebro.reviews

Amangiri

Place · Hotels, resorts, hostels & rentals · 32 mentions · 1 subreddit · discussed in r/FATTravel

Reddit take

AI summary of the Reddit excerpts below — not a quote

Amangiri is a highly polarizing luxury resort in Utah, known for its striking desert architecture and access to unique outdoor activities. While it remains a bucket-list destination for its location and aesthetic, recent feedback is sharply divided. Many travelers report a significant decline in service standards and food quality, suggesting the property currently struggles to justify its extreme price point, which can exceed $5,000 per night.

Pros

  • Stunning desert location with a world-class pool and unique architecture.
  • Excellent access to outdoor activities including slot canyons, hiking trails, and Lake Powell.
  • Pet-friendly policy for luxury travelers with animals.
  • Unique wellness experiences such as sound baths.
  • Adult-oriented atmosphere often described as a 'no kids' environment.

Cons

  • Inconsistent service and poor responsiveness from management.
  • Food quality issues, including reports of stale bread and undercooked dishes.
  • Maintenance lapses such as uncleaned private pools and empty propane heaters.
  • Perceived as a 'soulless' environment dominated by social media influencers.
  • Poor value proposition for the high cost, especially for 'splurge' travelers.

Caveats

  • Recent reviews suggest the property has 'gone downhill' compared to its historical reputation.
  • The desert climate can be unexpectedly cold; travelers are warned they may be chilly even without snow.
  • Service and dining are frequently cited as inferior to other top-tier luxury properties like Twin Farms.

Best for

  • Architecture and landscape enthusiasts.
  • Travelers seeking high-end access to Utah's slot canyons and natural landmarks.
  • Pet owners looking for a ultra-luxury desert retreat.

Avoid if

  • You expect flawless service and gourmet dining as a baseline for high nightly rates.
  • You are bothered by 'influencer' culture and social media-centric atmospheres.
  • You are looking for a high-value 'stretch' trip where every detail must be perfect.

This summary uses balanced time weighting with about a 18-month half-life. The evidence comes from 16 mentions in the r/FATTravel community with a median source age of approximately 10 months.

Sentiment

13 positive (41%) · 7 mixed (22%) · 12 negative (38%)

Trust + time weighted score: +3% · raw score 3%

What redditors said (10 of 32)

Amangiri. You won’t have the streets and bars but definitely a moody November recharge.
positive · u/F****2 · r/FATTravel · comment · Jul 24, 2026 · open on Reddit ↗
Amangiri is on the list.. important to me: spa, dining; important to my husband: nature accessibility and uniqueness.
positive · u/S****7 · r/FATTravel · Jul 19, 2026 · open on Reddit ↗
I've been to Amangiri four times over the last decade. The more it goes up in price, the worse it gets. Our last stay was two years ago and it was just OK. The property is beautiful but everything else is just a bit "meh." At $5,000 a day, it needs to be better than "meh."
mixed · u/v****f · r/FATTravel · comment · Jun 23, 2026 · open on Reddit ↗
Amangiri is cool too, but I don't feel it blows you away either.
mixed · u/i****w · r/FATTravel · comment · Jun 23, 2026 · open on Reddit ↗
Amangiri post Ranch Inn Dunton Hot Springs BlackBerry Farm/Mountain
positive · u/O****5 · r/FATTravel · comment · Jun 23, 2026 · open on Reddit ↗
depend what you looking for, all different but I would say Post Ranch Inn, Twin Farms, Amangiri and Amangani
positive · u/a****s · r/FATTravel · comment · Jun 23, 2026 · open on Reddit ↗
If you're looking for a traditional luxury resort where the primary value is flawless service and dining I think it's difficult to justify US$30k for three nights. Where Amangiri becomes special is when you engage with the landscape and activities. ... The setting is unlike almost anywhere else I've been. ... There is a certain atmosphere and sense of place that I found genuinely magical.
positive · u/b****t · r/FATTravel · comment · Jun 5, 2026 · open on Reddit ↗
To be completely frank, I think you may be disappointed with the service. It doesn’t live up to the standards set by Asian luxury hotels—although I’d argue that nowhere in America does. ... The food is mostly a hit, with a few misses, but I could eat their breakfast pancake until I die. It’s magnificent. ... I’ve been a few times and really love it, but I acknowledge that it does have some flaws.
mixed · u/F****t · r/FATTravel · comment · Jun 5, 2026 · open on Reddit ↗
Honestly, no. When it was $2,500/night it was worth it. ... The last time we went in 2023 we paid $3,500/night and it was the exact same product as 2016. We probably won’t go again unless the prices drop or the product is improved in some way.
mixed · u/T****9 · r/FATTravel · comment · Jun 5, 2026 · open on Reddit ↗
Definitely not worth it, spent like $35k for a long weekend there and was definitely not worth it
negative · u/t****3 · r/FATTravel · comment · Jun 5, 2026 · open on Reddit ↗

Compare

Related

  • Rome · related · 343 mentions
  • Venice · related · 315 mentions
  • Florence · related · 294 mentions
  • Bologna · related · 259 mentions
  • Paris · related · 217 mentions
  • Kyoto · related · 206 mentions